Some of the issues I’ve noticed with the current Shadow Priest design and few ides on how to fix them.
- Spirit Tap - great for leveling but frustrating for group content and almost useless for end game PvE, especially long raid boss fights with no adds.
- Vampiric Embrace - using VE to proc spirit tap makes the spell confusing. On one hand you want to use it as a utility spell to heal up your party, but on the other you are incentivized to use it to fish for Spirit Tap procs
- Devouring Plague - CD to duration ratio is awkward. It creates this weird flow while killing mobs in the wild where you’ll be slightly stronger for one and than slightly weaker for the next.
- Devouring contagion - is lackluster as an AoE utility. The mana reduction is nice (but boring) but this talent should be used to give SP some small amount of proper AoE.
- Shadowform - is way to powerful and because of it a lot of SP power is backloaded.
Solution ideas:
Don’t take the numbers too seriously, all of these would need to be properly tested and dialed in of course
- Spirit Tap - instead of procing on last hit change it so it has a small chance to proc any time you deal shadow damage (similar to Blackout).
- I find “last hit” dependencies very awkward and frustrating. No issues when you are doing solo things but in group setting it’s incredibly frustrating trying to proc it while everyone else is blasting the enemy.
- Either give it a relatively good chance of procing and internal cooldown or no internal cooldown but very low chance of procing. Dial in the numbers so it doesn’t affect solo leveling while giving some endgame utility.
- In order to not make SPs have too much mana regen Shadowform should be slightly nerfed (more on that below).
- Vampiric Embrace - the whole Spirit Tap interaction should be removed, since Spirit Tap would be able to proc on it’s own during a fight.
- Make the VE a proper utility cooldown:
- Increase the CD to 3-5 minutes
- Lower the duration to 10-15 second
- Make it into a personal buff instead of a debuff on the enemy (mainly to avoid potential misses)
- Drastically increase the % of your damage it heals. I’m talking 50% to 100%.
- This way VE becomes a proper party/raid utility that can be used tactically or in a case of emergencies but, due to it’s long cooldown, doesn’t become the defining feature of the SP. Shadow Priests should be primarily DPS spec and not turn into what discipline eventually became in retail (healing while dealing damage)
- Make the VE a proper utility cooldown:
- Devouring Plague - Lower the CD to 30 second. Yes this is a straight up buff but i honestly don’t think this would make SP OP. As always some numbers tweaking is needed to not make them broken, but having DP always available would make the solo leveling experience much smoother.
- Devouring Contagion - this one is a bit tough cause i want to give SP at least some AoE without making them actually be amazing at AoE. Class identity is very important for classic and AoE just isn’t what SPs should be known for.
- Idea 1 - Make DC spread DP to multiple targets not just the 1 nearest one. Two potential issues with this is that priests will time the DP right before a mob dies so that a almost full duration DP spreads, and the second one is this might give SPs way too much self heal, especially in PVP. Solution.
Potential solution to both: instead of Devouring Plague spreading make it a different debuff (different spell ID), I’m just gonna call it “Lingering Plague” for RP purposes. Make it last half of the full DP duration and have it not heal the SP for the damage it deals. - Idea 2 - this one i don’t really like because it’s a bit to retail-y but i make it so that when you are using mind flay on a target that has DP, some of the mind flay damage is splashed and hit all other targets nearby.
- Idea 1 - Make DC spread DP to multiple targets not just the 1 nearest one. Two potential issues with this is that priests will time the DP right before a mob dies so that a almost full duration DP spreads, and the second one is this might give SPs way too much self heal, especially in PVP. Solution.
- Devouring Contagion - this one is a bit tough cause i want to give SP at least some AoE without making them actually be amazing at AoE. Class identity is very important for classic and AoE just isn’t what SPs should be known for.
- Shadowform - As i said Shadowform is way to powerful and SP is way too backloaded. Simple fix to balance the fact that Spirit Tap can now proc during fights is to lower the mana discount Shadowform gives from 50% to 30-40% (again proper testing is needed to find the sweet spot)