Professions, Knowledge Points and their catch-ups

Hello everyone (and hopefully blizzard).

I consider myself a completionist and actually very much enjoy the new crafting system that came in since Dragonflight. I do however have growing concerns regarding the Knowledge point system given they are now in their third expansion and how it is scaling.

Firstly, I have all professions, most recipes in the game, and i complete the weekly KP tasks / Crafting orders on cool-down and have done for some time now. I am starting to notice a few issues appearing as this system ages namely;

Catching up for newer players / people who are just getting started is becoming unnecessarily tedious, very time consuming and not at all engaging.You now need to go to Valdrakken, Dornogol and Silvermoon City (Midnight) to collect the profession Knowledge Point crafting order weeklies on each character which will be your main source of KP income for previous X-pac’s as current crafting orders only award current X-pacs KP. This is not only time consuming but also buggy, Today i noticed that whilst DF and Midnight Weekly KP crafting order quests completed, TWW quest was bugged and Midnight’s crafting order quest did not award progress towards it making it impossible to complete. This was the same for several other professions I’ve tried.

The time investment now needed to ‘complete’ all knowledge points in a previous expansions professions is unreasonably long (1-2 years without if you decide to god forbid take a break or some time off) and has no reason to be anymore.Current expansion knowledge point gains should remain slow similar to farming T-mogs, that makes sense, but i strongly believe a catch-up for legacy knowledge points should be considered even if that only includes putting (working) Knowledge point weekly quests on the 1 vendor in midnight (and whatever the current X-pac is going forward)

On a slightly more broad note, the sheer amount of legacy content in this game now is becoming insurmountable for new players, demoralizing for anyone who wants to get started, and for anyone who “fell off” or wants to get started again is very off putting.

Sadly, it’s become quite frankly outright absurd in the time investment it requires of you if you just want to clean up your collections and this is now another metric to measure that by.

If this isn’t fixed or addressed by Blizzard even slightly, I’d like anyone who reads this and actually engages or enjoys the new profession systems to imagine where we’ll be in 1,2,3 X-pacs from now regarding trying to catch up on professions (much less anything else).. It will fast become one of the most time consuming things to complete in game.

Now, enough whinging from me and a few solutions I’ve considered:

  1. Legacy KP Buff Based On Expansion Age.
    Once an expansion is no longer current, all KP gains from that expansion should be accelerated, for example:
  • Current expansion = normal rates;
  • 1 expansion old = +100% KP gains
  • 2 expansions old = +250%
  • 3+ expansions old = effectively uncapped catch-up

This preserves prestige during current content while respecting us players’ time later.

  1. Account-Wide Profession Knowledge Catch-Up
    If one character has maxed a profession tree for an expansion, alts should gain accelerated KP gains for that same profession/tree and/or allow the completed profession to trade KP’s on a vendor (maybe with a small tax) for alt profession KPs e.g. 10 Blacksmith KPs for 8 Alchemy/Engineering etc. This avoids;
  • Repeating identical weekly grinds
  • Feeling punished for experimenting with alts
  • Profession burnout

This also aligns with modern Blizzard’s broader “war-band/account-wide” philosophy.

  1. One Centralized Weekly Hub
    All legacy profession weeklies should be consolidated into the current X-pacs capital city. This reduces:
  • Travel friction
  • Quest bugs
  • Confusion for newer players

It also future-proofs the system instead of adding another city every single expansion.

  1. Knowledge Decay Removal/Auto-Completion for Old Trees
    For very old X-pacs, Blizzard could simply unlock baseline nodes automatically. For example;
  • Generic throughput nodes auto-complete
  • Only specialization/rare recipe paths remain progression-based

This Keeps meaningful choices while removing all the pointless filer nodes and grinding.

  1. Profession Renown Vendor
    Similar to point 2, A vendor that lets you trade excess current-X-pacs profession materials/currencies for legacy KP items. That creates;
  • A small gold/material sink
  • A reason to engage with current crafting
  • A deterministic catch-up path
  1. Exploration-Based Catch-Up Instead of Weekly Lockouts
    We players do so so much in game already. It could come in small part from some or even all of the following and more;
  • Rare drops
  • Dungeon rewards
  • Treasure hunting
  • Delves/world activities
  • Old raid bosses
  • Achievement milestones

That turns catch-up into game-play instead of yet another calendar and spreadsheet management.

If you made it this far well done, gold star, and i hope this seems reasonable and a good idea.

I’m sure there will be many other opinions on this but if i were in charge of Blizzards profession curation/development this is just how i would consider fixing this problem before it becomes a much bigger one and an even bigger mess.

~ Shmee

2 Likes

“Legacy KP catch-ups” is something i think is at the very bottom of the list of pressing issues that needs to get fixed in wow rn. I dont even think blizzard has even given that a first thought that it should even be possible to farm legacy KP, to the point that it might even be an accidental feature.

Why would you even want to level KP for legacy content? Is it important to be able to craft rank 5 of some dragnflight BS weapon or is rank 1 not enough?

This stopped being true after Legion, when you had to level 600 skill points of legacy prof levels before you could start levelling legion engineering.

This i think would accelerate the problem of people having concentration armies

This entire KP system just needs to go.
We’re forced to spend hours chasing RNG drops for a few measly points every week.

Whoever thought this was a fun and engaging systems should be banned from every touching games again.

4 Likes

Completionism. In a word.

If you’re talking solely about professions yes, but that’s not at all what i said. There are huge communities of completionists in wow and wow itself has become a collection farm-simulator as evident by the 266,837 individual collectable items that are now in World of Warcraft and the now over 7000 Achievements, many of which are individually insane all by themselves and award nothing by 10 Achievement points.

Subverting that by just shrinking it down to “At least we don’t have to farm old professions to level new ones anymore so it’s not true” is a disingenious whataboutism when that’s not what the massive post I made was referring to.

Concentration armies are not new and are just the latest iteration of people deeply investing into professions to make money which isn’t an issue at all and has existed since Vanilla / TBC when people would make multiple characters with Alchemy to make multiple Arcanite/Primal Mights to make money. This wasn’t an issue then, hasn’t been an issue since, and isn’t an issue now. Moot point.

Also, The weekly TWW profession quests are now bugged for (from what i’ve seen) the 4th/5th week in a row and are still unable to be completed.

I don’t mind them trying new systems, but i largely agree. It feels like the whole design of KP’s had it’s ankles shackled by blizzards typical old philosophy of time-gating and forcing players to stay subscribed for long periods to complete medial tasks and finish grinds rather than just letting them go at it at their own pace.

if they want to poop-sock it and no life it and get there a little earlier, let them. There’s enough in this game and has been for many years now to not require time-gating and trivial grind-limiting.

1 Like

As someone who only get Alchemy & Enchanting on ally my characters for longer flasks + disenchant items I don’t need; I would like to get into professions but when I saw what was needed to even get Epic Profession equipment on all my chars I called it quits. I don’t like the work orders etc and I find the UI and systems in general are poorly designed and messy. Same with professions in general.

I have concluded with that I want professions to mean more, and I feel like oldschool runescape do that better than wow ever has. I will never chose gathering professions above anything else, but I still find it somewhat annoying that I can’t herb/mine when I stumble upon some.

If professions were tied to my character as a progression, I would invest the time and effort as it’s something I can work towards and eventually complete until new content comes along. I guess I’m similar as OP, a completionist.

I wish all my characters could have all professions but have specialities that made me put extra effort into specific ones. For example; most of my characters all have fishing max level. I used to have First Aid as well, and some of my characters have archaeology maxed as well. I will never swap out the advantages I as an M+ player get from Alch & Ench. At heart, I’d prefer having engineering and jewelcrafting, but that wont happen.

In game should be similar as in real life; I should be able to dabble in various “professions” on an entry level, but only where I put time and effort in is what I’ll excel at. I think that would be a good addition to the game.

Well said. This bothers me as well. The game has way too much timegating in general and the KPs are just one of them.

I am progressing mining and blacksmithing with my main character. It has felt tedious for weeks now and it is hard to motivate myself to do mining and treasure chest runs weekly just to collect the needed KPs. The KP items drops are also based on RNG which makes the system even worse.

During TWW I tried to cover all the professions with my alts but it was way too much hassle and time consuming which finally burned me. Now I am focusing only on these two professions and I am still not happy with the system.

In conclusion, Blizzard, less timegating and RNG for professions and actually in general too. The gearing (and upgrading) timegating with all the tight gaps is getting out of hand.

I’ve just decided to start filling out all my knowledge point nodes from Dragonflight. To think that it’s going to take years just because a catch-up hasn’t been implemented is really saddening. Really hope Blizzard addresses this soon!

Absolutely. This is a massive issue for me when it comes to levelling alts, etc.

This topic was automatically closed 30 days after the last reply. New replies are no longer allowed.