Im going to show you a basic comparison of what each tank has in there kit and yes yes I know you can’t really 100% rate a hero in a vacuum but I dont think you really need too deep of depth when you see how out of balance the RAW numbers are below. Sry for typos btw trying to smash this out at work.
To start what stand out to me is how utterly broken DVA is there is no way in hell she has a balanced win rate. Literally god tier in the 3 main core features of tank; Tankiness unbeliveable stat line with stupid level of armor, mobility easily the best, damage output combo that can insta most 200 health target WITHOUT even damage boosting.
When you compare her to doomfist it is laughably bad. Doom has NO armor health regen and defense that is so bad you benefit from just shooting him at all times. Cooldowns that make zero sense and promote never actully punching anyone so mobility is pointless. A laughable ult that even bronze players can dodge not that they entirely need to.
Blizzard seriously needs to make more significant lines between diver and static tank because there is so much over lap leading to certain hereos having everything and others having nothing. Doom wouldnt need to be buffed upwards if divers were equal to his level and things like armor were reserved for tanks that cant move well.
I would bet my life Doom win rate is way lower than DVA, now you can still argue doom is annoying and u dont want him in the game but thats a different argument but its not just about these 2 there is tons of inconsistency in the stat lines and abilities. Ball and Junker queen are others I feel have total bullshet stat lines comparatively to the stronger tanks. 15 SECONDS FOR SHOUT what the actul fk ? stupidly lazy nerf.
Im very worried the balance team have zero clue what they are doing to release DVA in current form is the most low IQ thing ive seen blizzard do she is literally good at everything. That is objectively bad game design ps did I forget to mention the increased verticality in maps benefits her massively.
Zarya 475/200 Regen - 225 sheild ever 5 seconds - unblockable death lazor
Ball 700/100 sheild - 100/600 sheild 15 seconds - slow machine gun - swing 5s
Winston 550/200 sheild - Jump 5s - 700 sheild 12 seconds - ragemode heal - trash gun
Sigma 550/200 Regen - 700 sheild - 3 seconds absorb - Slow bombs
Hog 700 - 350 health/mit - death hook 7s - trash gun
Rein 625/300 sheild - 1200 sheild - spear 8s - 100 damage pen 5s - powerful CC ULT - massive damage axe
Orisa 550/275 ARMOR ?! wtf high 7s invunerable 12s invunerable 6s CC projectile fast firing machine gun
Junkerqueen 425 ?! so low -200 health 15 seconds ?! -Powerful high damage attacks -Trash ultimate
Doomfist 450 ?! - Fast but not the fastest - Low damage - 3s block total trash - trash ultimate - slow firing low range gun
DVA 650/300 ARMOR ?!? WTF
BEST mobility in the game fly
powerful damage combo
5second absorb INCLUDING ULTS
pro invis revaler
ULT powerful bomb always value HEAL TO FULL AND KILL remech !?!?
powerful pistol