I have 60+ hours this week playing SSF, 200+ Prime evil kills to complete ONE set for wirt’s coin. My first hellfire torch is beautiful, perfect rolls and the set i use, but when i put it on it does not work for the set I’m wearing (and through some experimentation it works with a completely different set). Combo this with being unable to pick up more than 1 splinter at a time, this process is VERY discouraging and kills the enjoyment of all the new stuff this season has to offer.
The same happened to me 
I have the same problem
Just looted another max-rolled torch that says it works with one set but does not XD. Losing my mind farming for this garbage on SSF
I got 2 charms 1 ancestral and 1 normal, with the normal hellfire torch the set is working lol ^^
mine which is normal doesnt work
Yup same issue here - nothing in the patch notes as well to say this is being fixed.
There is no way this is still not fixed i got one with 2 GA’s it says it counts to +1 set of the Berserker’s Crucible. But it does not like how is this possible and still in the game!!!