Critique My Game?

General Discussion
1

Is there a possibility that we could have a “Critique My Game” topic, where players will post their previous games and better players will critique some of them, like telling their mistakes? Just a suggestion.

2

It would be hard to remeber every difficult turn I think. But if you could remember turns you weren’t sure about that would be a great thing to see happen in the hs community.

1 Like
3

If you start one up and post a hsreplay link, you’ll get plenty of opinions, the majority of which will be really helpful to improve your game. Just got to cut through it all and ignore the stuff that doesn’t make sense.

1 Like
4

Yeah I was thinking about using HSreplay too, just post links and wait for the critiques. Also everyone can critique the games of lower rated players. Very helpful in my opinion

1 Like
5

Indeed.

I will say that it’s a pretty bad time to ask about this, simply because in 2 days time, every answer will be potentially wrong until the meta settles unless you’re playing a paint by numbers deck and even if you are, the first step would be almost certainly to improve your deck :grin:

1 Like
6

Yeah you’re right. Still though, when the meta settles, it will be useful

2 Likes
7

Really good idea… i like it :slight_smile:

1 Like
8

Agreed, great idea. I, unfortunately, play most of my games on mobile so it wouldn’t be much use to me, but I’d be happy to offer opinions and tips on other peoples game play. Would also be good learning experience for new players to watch other peoples games and see the advice the more seasoned players offer

1 Like
9

Everyone was very positive about this idea so I created it: Critique My Game
Thanks to everyone!