I have had 4 accounts to date, in February of this year I was a low Silver player. I climbed to Gold on my main account and eventually into low Plat.
This is when I made my first “smurf” account. It placed in Gold and eventually climbed into Plat.
As I learned more about the game and got better I eventually reached Diamond and made my way up to high Diamond. I’m currently playing at 3100 and I’m still being accused of Smurfing (despite the fact that this account placed 2300) and aimhacking.
What I’m trying to say is that all 4 of my accounts ended up exactly where they belong.
You have to remember that while one hero is viable in X SR, it may not be viable in a different ELO entirely. Brig is amazing when played in Goats Comp (3 Tanks, 3 Supports) but she is not a main healer and cannot support an entire team by herself. Players in Bronze don’t understand the game at a basic level and Brig is the worst hero to play if you want to gain any sort of mechanical skill or understanding of gamesense/positioning in order to climb.
It’s very comforting to believe, as a low SR player that you’re made for great things and that you can climb high and that surely you’re not THAT bad at the game but in truth, you are. I remember recording games from when I was low Silver to show my friends and ask them why the Hell I was in Silver when I played much more like a Plat or Diamond player, but looking back at them now. I BELONGED in Silver because I made mistakes like a Silver player.
The game is a lot more complex than at first it seems. For example, on this account I play almost exclusively Tracer. I have played Tracer for probably 85-90% of all my competitive games, regardless of team composition.
With this changing meta, I don’t play Tracer the way I always used to. There are multiple different playstyles that you can execute depending on your enemy team’s setup and your team’s set up.
As a quick example: If I’m playing Tracer and we have a Widowmaker who can hit shots but is being harassed by enemy tanks. And keeps getting killed. What’s the first thing your team is likely to do?
“SWITCH WIDOW YOU SUCK.”
This tilts the Widowmaker and makes her play badly and less likely to switch. In this case, the tanks could protect her and give her SPACE. Space is the ability to execute your role without being harassed, making you much more likely to succeed.
At lower SRs, tanks are played like DPS heroes. They are not often used to defend the dps or supports to create space. This is one of the reasons why Widowmaker has a much lower pick rate at low SR.
Back to the scenario. My tanks aren’t peeling for the Widow so what do I do? I take the highground with her and help to peel so that she can kill the supports and be effective in helping us win the teamfight.
Now, if we have a Junkrat on the other hand, I’m much more likely to be in the backline and harassing the enemy supports whilst my Junkrat assists the tanks in the frontline.
The higher the SR, the more safe I play. In Gold I could likely teamkill every teamfight just by one clipping the supports from the flank while the frontline is busy. But as you get higher, more people are using comms, more people understand their role. Whereas a gold Zenyatta would likely be oblivious to me in the backline, if I tried to kill their Mercy without my team’s help, I would likely get pistol whipped by Mercy and headshot by Zenyatta if I tried the same tactic in Masters or higher.
TL;DR Playstyle/hero choice varies greatly depending on the ELO you’re in. You can’t just play the same way you would in Gold as you would in Diamond. Aside from generally better mechanics, each skill tier has its own things to consider. I’d probably rank them something like this:
Bronze:
Total chaos, terrible mechanics, terrible positioning, little or no communication, no good team composition, no idea how the game works.
Silver:
Bronze but with very slightly better mechanics.
Gold:
Dramatically better mechanics compared to Bronze, usually understands that 2/2/2 increases your chance of winning vs 6 dps.
Platinum:
Mechanics steadily increasing, counter picks start occurring, map awareness increased, small understanding of when to play aggressive and when to be defensive.
Instead of focusing on where you think you should be, focus only on conquering the ELO that you’re in.
If you’re below Gold, focus only on your mechanics. Mechanics alone will take you into Gold. Once you reach Gold, begin to play like a Platinum player, continue to work on your mechanics but also start focusing on grouping up and trying to coordinate plays with your team. Graviton Surge, Earth Shatter, Blizzard + basically any other offensive ult can be devastating because most teams can’t or won’t have any answer for it. The same reason Pharah/Mercy is so strong in low ELO because most hitscan players simply don’t have the mechanics to take them out.
Anyway, I’ve rambled on long enough, I hope this helps a little and if you have any questions, please feel free to ask away