Nobody wants the trashy Holy Shield talent, its so bad. We all wanted something else, your answer is to rebuild the protection tree forcing us all to use it?
We cant have our different ways of playing anymore.
Also, what is this moving around of the talent tree? Its awful!
This is not what we asked for!
Same with hunter, the talent trees was so much better before, now you are forced to go heavy into BM tree and leaves no room for different builds
1 Like
I agree, that there are better skills than Holy Shield, but it isn’t as bad as you say either.
Tune down the whine a little bit
3 Likes
If by “a little bit you mean a lot” then I fully agree!
Holy shield only has 4 charges. It has a 10 sec cd. It costs mana. Now they gave us holy strike to spam, also costing mana.
Holy shield have very limited up time as 4 charges wears off fast and you are stuck with a long CD.
Its atleast something, in somewhat correct direction.
But they had so many options and so many good suggestions on the forums and they just doubled down on the terrible holy shield.
6 second holy strike cd. 10 sec holy shield cd. 4 charges, such a limited window to combine it. Holy shield itself needs reworked not forced down our throat as it is.
1 Like
Holy shield is a core tanking ability. I don’t know what is wrong about that.
It could be better ofc. I’d like it to have synergy with redoubt to make that one also not a lackluster anymore, but devs do dev things 
3 Likes
There is no instance in a raid or dungeon boss that Holy Shield is ever used up. This new capstone is a massive improvement for all single target, while preserving our ability in AoE.
That is the best we could have asked for.
Holy Shield was never a bad ability, boring sure, bad. No.
1 Like
Just saw some data mining showing holy shield also blocks spells, that’s seems to be really cool.
Also, isn’t it just rank 1 holy shield which has 4 stacks? I can’t see other ranks to have 4 stacks. At least in the tooltip
I really like holy shield when tanking
4 Likes
well with new capstone it’s now 8 charges - 4 charges from holy shield itself and another 4 from the new capstone (unless i understood incorrectly the part about triggering holy shield)
There is nothing wrong with Holy Shield. It’s long been a core talent of the “classic” Prot paladin kit. You should all be worried about the removal of Improved Seal of Fury, because Prot paladins will not have the mana to use their new tools + consecration with these new changes.
We don’t really need big changes or anything. We just need basic stuff so that the classes and specs are playable.
2 Likes
No not really how it works.
By the looks of it Shieldsworn the new 31 point talent reduces Holy strike from 10 sec to 6 sec CD. It also restores 4% mana and activates one charge worth of Holy Shield (If you have it activated). Without spending the charge.
If you use your Holy Shield, you have 4 charges and 10 seconds cooldown, you use your Holy Strike after GCD. During the duration of Holy Shields uptime yiu only get one Holy Strike in. Resulting in a total of 5 charges from Holy Shield instead of 4.
Sounds good on paper…
To make it easier to understand the actual effects:
Shieldsworn gives u 5 charges of Holy Shield instead of 4. It also makes Holy Strike restore 4% Mana. Also allows you to block spells for 6 seconds.
Seeing as they are forcing Holy Shield down our throat they should redo how it works, make it last 15 sec, no charges but reduce the effect or something. This is just flashy with not much practical use.
Holy shield is still trash
I want to use it, your premises is wrong, close the thread!
1 Like
They got told on the forums that Holy Shield is bad and everyone wants Avengers shield, HoTr or something else. Instead they force us to spend more talent points to buff Holy Shield by such a small margin.
We wanted something to either range pull or compete with Swipe/Cleave.
But they just overcomplicated something useless
And reduce forbearance by 10 seconds? Id rather take my 4% Stamina boost…
1 Like
Holy shield does 221 dmg + 0.08 spell power scaling and 20% additional threat and you will also get a small bit of mana back now each time you use Holy Strike. So it will actually be a quite meaningful button to press. The wording suggest that the extra damage will only be dealt if you have an active Holy Shield up with at least 1 charge even though that charge will not be consumed then. Or maybe it always adds the extra damage. That little mana won’t compensate for the removal of Improved Seal of Fury though. Would suck if consecration usage makes you go oom…
Well with us now prefering to spec down to Sacred Arbiter in the ret tree and missing out on Holy Conduit we are 100% sure to go OOM if we want to use Concecration.
And the coefficients are just a joke considering the low amounts of spelldamage is on paladin gear thats already been mined/seen ingame.
We are much better off just going Str/Ap at this point. Again paladin losing flavor and identity. Gives me a sour taste not being able to use its potential thats right there in front of us because devs wants paladin a certain way(Single target tank only). As Warrior/Druid is by far better AoE tanks now(But guess what? Also better Single target).
Id rather have Paladin before these changes and that was a bad version of it.
I feel like they are trying too hard to make paladins into something they aint and nobody wants them to be…
Also why are Swift Judgement on a 1 minute CD? Put it down to 30 sec.
Atm paladin have 7 Taunts per minute costing mana.
Warriors have 10 taunts. Free of charge.
Druids have 6 Taunts per minute, + Swipe, + Primal Bite + Lacerate & AoE taunt.
1 Like
Feeling you.
I dont want msw either, still there.
Just a food for thought - i know it’s not a reliable info at this point, but it seems like rank 2/rank 3 have no charges at all in spell description lol
I didn’t think I would see a paladin complaint post today. they had two bubbles now they have a magic bubble. I not sure what else blizzard can throw at them to make them happy?
2 Likes
Remove all bubbles if thats so “OP” lol. Id rather have some proper skills instead of a bubble that loses me all aggro and gives me forbearance
2 Likes
Talk about yourself. I want my paladin to buff his shield and increase his block chance. Similar to shield block of warrior
1 Like