I’m playing Ret at this moment and it’s not like it’s weak (number-wise), because that’s not exactly the case - it’s quite decent in terms of single target damage BUT:
There is pretty much no build variety, you either go full Ret, full Prot or full Holy - with one extra build that is Shockadin - most of the talents are either “we expect that you take this one” or “we expect you won’t take this one because it’s bad and we know it” - I suppose it’s the case for many if not all classes, but yeah - it’s a problem here too
Ret has literally like 3 clickable combat buttons + maybe HoJ once a minute, all the rest is just not really viable - Seal of Crusader judgement doesn’t seem to increase Seal of Command holy damage (at least in my personal tests) so is pretty weak for Ret as judgement and probably similar for other specs, this class screams for one or even two more extra buttons to press as part of normal rotation that gives the spec more agency than looking at auto attack and pressing 1 button every 5 seconds
RNG based - too much RNG in general, you either evaporate enemy with devastating crits within second or hit like a wet noodle for 20 seconds, Unsealed Wrath pushes RNG even further because even if you stack Seal of Command 3 times, they are not guaranteed to proc …so on release nothing may happen or enemy explodes in red cloud of guts - or something in between, also UW has quite long windup time before you actually “load” the seals, because it’s not a button you can press to drop a nuke, in general UW doesn’t look like fun capstone
A little bit lack of soft CC - for example we have Repentance and HoJ as our source of hard CC - both at 1 min CD which is quite long compared to most other classes (especially HoJ, I think it should be 30s), Paladin screams for at least ability to slow enemies (let it be slowing seal that you can judge against, it would be fine), we have Seal of Justice but again - it’s RNG, so either enemy will be nearly stunlocked and pummeled to death with nuclear crits or …nothing will happen
Zero cleave and pathetic AoE - yeah, this is the moment where I may get the idea what this extra “combat button to press” should be, and it should probably be something that allows to cleave at least 2 enemies (something like Retail Prot shield bounce for example), let’s be honest - with one such skill Paladin is not going to “outcleave” a Warrior, but at least one more thing to press, Consecration is “kinda cleave” because it’s basically doing damage to 4 enemies - but even these 4 enemies won’t feel a thing, it’s just too weak and too expensive, even with plenty of mana and multiple Consecrations at every pull - you will barely notice its effect on DPS meter, I prefer it to be expensive and powerful over cheap and weak - now however it’s expensive and weak, for Prot it would be most important for Consecration to be uncapped, for Ret because of Champion of the Light it should hit like a truck, but base is just very bad anyway
Judgement should have longer range - 20 ft or even 30 ft, it would help both Prot and Ret, for Prot to pull and for Ret to maybe apply some seal (slowing seal judged from 20-30 ft would be VERY nice)
I don’t think Paladin should have any kind of gap closer. I think class identity is to be very sturdy and constantly oppressive, but not very mobile - but for that it would require some ability to slow enemies and have some more ranged ability. That being said, it REALLY needs at least one more button to push from time to time, at least on Ret. Unsealed Wrath is just bad, I would rather have something like capstone turning Consecration into single AoE nuke rather than DOT (so basically Divine Storm).
The point of build variety is kinda just wrong to begin with, as you very easily get a prot-ret and prot-holy build going without getting too weird for tanking, and you can very easily sacrifice the prot final talent if going for an aoe and dungeon build for example. And that’s before going for stranger niche things, as I could genuinely see a wacky holy/prot/ret build working acceptably well.
As for AoE… you have consecration, this is what ret paladins always had. If you want more aoe, don’t go full ret and either bank on more spell focus with holy, or more thorns focus with prot. Ret is specifically about strong single target hits with a two hander weapons. You can’t seriously pick the single target build and expect to beat more versatile builds at aoe and cleave
I’m not saying that other classes have no problems, but I believe all classes should be “fun to play”, just with different playstyles. Ret is mostly auto attack playstyle right now, and even if it kinda works for DPS metrics - it just sucks to play like that.
As a “veteran” (since 2005) Paladin player, I really enjoy the current Retribution playstyle, it feels right at home in Vanilla, while being more viable and having a couple more buttons to press. EXCEPT… I haven’t taken the capstone talent. I’ve gone 21/0/30 which feels far more interesting and versatile. The Paladin class as a whole has the most boring capstone talents in the entire game.
And how is Shockadin doing? I believe you need lvl 60 for true Shockadin, because you also need Champion of Light. But yeah, this extra button to press is speaking to me much louder than “wait some unspecified amount of time to maybe (if you don’t miss) stash 3 charges that will maybe fire or not when you switch seal”.
While leveling up there isn’t a huge difference, really, you won’t have Shockadin specific gear, so it’s nearly identical with an extra button. You have to go Ret first and respec once you have enough talents to go deep enough into Ret after 21 in Holy. I still use SoC but once geared with heavy spell damage, in theory SoR should be superior. Tbh SoR is a very boring seal, and that’s a bit of a problem with this spec. Win some, lose some.
Somewhere in an area 10 levels below what they should be doing wanding everything to death one mob at a time.
Yes, I’m still doing it. But seeing people nag about their class not being op enough is kinda funny. You really should try holy priest dps and then go back to warlock or rogue or whatever the sad spec of the moment is and it’ll feel completely op.
(this is not about the pala, but about the warlock comment)
Seems like it’s better to level with Unsealed Wrath to be honest. That being said - it won’t stop Paladin from being 2 button class. On one hand we have like 3 flavours of bubbles, 3 flavours of heals - all of them (beside basic heal) are “oh crap” buttons that you use once every 4 hours, we have auras that are fire-and-forget (and Retribution aura also sucks if you are not Prot), blessings that you apply once per hour (Blessing of Freedom should be special and not override existing blessing, because it’s just annoying to re-apply blessing later), and very weak barely working AoE (Consecration) that they made baseline, but at the same time nerfed it right to the ground so it doesn’t do anything worth mentioning.
Too many “oh crap”, not enough actual combat agency. On higher levels we have Hammer of Wrath also, but it really screams for at least one more button NOT being RNG as part of the rotation, best if it would be some kind of cleave attack.
In PvP situations it really feels like Paladin kit is lacking meaningful utility. Other classes feel like they have several tricks in their box, very long CCs that they can use often, multiple damaging abilities - both ranged and melee in some times, and paladin has tools …but most of best ones are RNG or very long CD. I get that with Paladin survivability they cannot have 5 flavours of CCs, gap closers and 8 damaging abilities, but two buttons and auto attack empowered by some RNG chance is quite bad. PvP be like “I just try to keep close to the guy to pummel him with AA”.
The fix is simple, but it would require them to backtrack on some decisions.
Remove unsealed wrath and add a talent that gives Seal of Blood and makes seals linger for 0.4 seconds, to enable REAL seal twisting for those who like it. Add Art of War (the SoD version, shortens the cd on Exorcism on crits) as an alternative capstone on the Retribution tree (only one can be picked). Make Exorcism hit everything baseline. Prot gets a ranged pull and one more button. Ret gets real seal twisting and an alternative play style on the ret tree. Holy gets their own tree back instead of having to accommodate Shockadin.