I’m not being funny but, when you have the WHOLE forum telling you to stay away from this guild, and i do mean the whole forum because we have;
The PCU
Athramus the Contrarian Dragon Who Doesn’t Agree With Anybody
Various one person guild posters
Guilds that are not in the PCU (despite what the OP thinks)
AND
The Bayerlyn Retinue
Of which, some of these groups NEVER agree with each other.
maybe when they have all banded together to be like; “this guild ain’t kosher dude” then maybe there’s some truth in what they say?
just a thought.