Guild Bank Missing Items Bug - Aug/Sept 2024

Well it was fun whilst it lasted but its time to move on i guess farewell!- ,someone in blizzard is laughing at us all i think!

6 Likes

Iā€™ve lost over 15 years collected (valuable) herbs, alchemy recipes and now u tell me u dont have a way to restore the missing items??!! Really??

5 Likes

Well, thatā€™s it, iā€™ve canceled my subscription. I donā€™t know for how long, but it really felt good to state my reasons in the ā€œother reasonā€ part of the cancel subscription form. This time my money is not going to Blizzard on the billing date.

6 Likes

I see from the comments that quite a few people think as I do: That they could recover the items if they really tried.

I could be wrong, but I think they are considering this only affecting a small amount of people and requiring a big amount of resources to deal with properly. Can we make a script to do this all with minimal effort. No? Well tell them we cant do it then.

As they dragged their heels on dealing with it for so long, it makes me wonder if there were backups they could have used and now these have been written over. I would be surprised if there were not any backups of the guild banks at all, but I guess in theory what is there could be compared to in/out logs. Though that would be stupid if the logs expire after a certain time and if they donā€™t expire then a restore should still be possible from that?

Itā€™s never going to happen, but I would like someone in the actual development team to provide detail about why they cant provide a restore for people affected. Clearly state that they have no backups of the bank contents to restore from and the reason why they have a design that retains no backups of bank contents.

Iā€™m really saddened to think that the answer could well be there arenā€™t enough people affected to make it worth their while allocating addition staff and time to resolving this. The original person tasked with solving this could well have a solution, but when brought to the bosses was told we donā€™t have the resources for that move on to something else

4 Likes

Iā€™m the same. When I first started playing TWW I was really enjoying it. That first look when you arrived at the entrance to Hallowfall was absolutely stunning and I just sat there for ages looking at the view. Iā€™d fly around and think ā€œwow, this is awesomeā€ ā€¦ the graphics guys did an amazing job.

Now ā€¦ I still see these things, and briefly Iā€™m impressed, and then I just feel sad. Itā€™s like a form of bereavement. I can enjoy it, for a brief moment, and then the sadness starts up.

And itā€™s not, in my case, the sadness for things lost, itā€™s sadness for the broken trust. Itā€™s been building for a while ā€¦ started when I was on a dead realm for over a decade and Blizzard promised to connect it with others and then broke that promise. It continued eroding as anything to do with guilds got gradually more and more broken, with no reaction from Blizzard.

Now itā€™s just gone. Iā€™m currently playing WoW for ā€œthe momentā€ and for my guild, but I canā€™t muster up that much enthusiasm any more - normally when thereā€™s a new mount, or a pet sale on, Iā€™d be tempted to buy something ā€¦ I didnā€™t even LOOK. Just couldnā€™t.

Currently itā€™s still my ā€œgo toā€ game ā€¦ not least because of my guild members ā€¦ but if something new comes along, Iā€™ll be seriously considering it. Iā€™ve paid my subscription non-stop since early 2007 ā€¦ I missed out on the ā€œrewardā€ for playing since Vanilla by a matter of a week or so. Iā€™ve bought pets and mounts from the shop. Iā€™ve bought 6 month and yearly subscriptions and Iā€™ve kept people playing the game who would have otherwise quit, when they joined our guild.

Iā€™m a drop in the ocean to Blizzard - I donā€™t count or matter - I know that. But it still all feels wrong and like a betrayal.

13 Likes

my complete bank is empty, 7 tabs, full of stuff, nearly 2 decades of stuff, pets, bags, cards, equip, stuff for reknown and a lot of more, nearly all tabs completely full. Till now I did not get any mail or stuff back. I lost my complete bank, 7 tabs full of stuff. this is absolutely not acceptable!!!

7 Likes

This is the feeling that many here now have, abandoned to their fate by their beloved company.

9 Likes

A thing to note is, that none of the ā€œbotters, farming sites, token farmers or alike has any issuesā€ ā€œblizzards own fat cows for milking microtransactionsā€

This let down by blizzard to some of their most caring customers over many many a years is DISGUSTING.
And had it not been in gaming, this would have caused an outrage in public papers and in the news and most likely any government would have to interfere and force the company in charge of this MASSIVE fail to redeem their customers in meaningful ways.

ā€¦

1 Like

A response to an earlier message I posted here
My latest ticket to Blizz (2 days ago).

Good morning

It is now Thursday and I still wanted to respond to the previous message. But I waited until the lethargy, disbelief and anger had subsided a bit.
I can understand that your hands are tied. But youā€™re not offering me anything, just waiting for the next ā€œrecoveryā€ wave. I have no confidence in that. I have read the forums both NA and EU. And Iā€™m just shocked at how your company is picking this up and handling this. There are rumors that top guilds and well-known streamers got their lost items back, and we are left with nothing. Next waves, another post mentions that there will be no other ā€œrecoveryā€ waves. And the post on the bug forum in NA is closed. Why closed, the problem is still not solved.
Years of effort and collecting simply disappeared due to incorrect coding. I urge you to bring this to the attention of the appropriate managers. so that an appropriate solution is initiated, next time take more time to test the game thoroughly. ā€œMeasure twice, cut onceā€. Listen to the Alpha and Beta testers. If no action is taken, vague answers. Youā€™ve lost me, ā€¦ If i cant trust a company to keep my items safe and secure in a bank. Then there is no reason to continue playing, because that means that everything I collect, achieve. Is meaningless, has no value assigned to it by your company. Yes this is a game, but I value it, it has meaning to me. And i am your customer .

Blizz answers:

This is game master Roodhephet from Blizzard Entertainment, Iā€™ll be the one assisting you today:)

Upon further checking into this issue, Iā€™m afraid that we as Game Masters are unable to assist in this case as itā€™s entirely something related to the developers. But we kindly ask you to submit your feedback on the World of Warcraft Forums.

Additionally, if thereā€™s anything else I can assist you with or if you have any further questions or concerns, please donā€™t hesitate to reach out.
Best regards,

So i am out , cancel subscription. Really sad how they handle this. Good luck everyone. Elvis has left the building.

10 Likes

I had precisely zero items restored from 7 full guild tabsā€¦ Hurrah for good support of the paying customers!

8 Likes

While I myself have been extremely lucky and lost nothing from this disaster, I feel for all of you who did. Blizzard is doing far too little to rectify this major screw-up they pushed out, which is complete bs.

10 Likes

Video game giant Activision Blizzard will start laying off employees at its Irvine and Santa Monica locations next month as parent company Microsoft Corp. looks to cut costs in its gaming division.

The Santa Monica-based video game maker notified about 400 employees of the layoffs on Sept. 12. By the end of the year, 140 employees will be cut from the Irvine facility and 110 will be laid off from the Santa Monica location, according to a state notification filed by Activision Blizzard.

Additionally, the companyā€™s Playa Vista location will begin layoffs in November and cut a total of 143 employees by the end of the year, according to a separate notice.

The Activision Blizzard layoffs are part of Microsoftā€™s move to cut 3% of its global gaming employees, or 650 people.

And what do we want after all this?

2 Likes

This?

The gradual layoffs will begin in small waves in mid-October and will be completed by the end of the year.

The application regarding the layoffs at Blizzard says that accountants, software engineers, the World of Warcraft HR director, artists, game producers and many others will be affected. The general list of positions to be cut includes not only junior employees: Activision Blizzard is also planning to fire the game director and vice president.

For now, this is the information. And then we will see.

It took them about a month to publicly address the issue - though at least via ticket response they could confirm it was a known issue. When they did address the issue, there was no apology or intent to compensate players for the items lost, even after confirming that there will be permanent data loss. Even more egregious: part of the lost data, the items they cannot restore, is still visible in the guild bank logs.

Itā€™s a simple story. They fudged up, sure, that can happen. But after that, they decided that rather than compensate players or spend time on manual solutions, itā€™d cost less money to just deal with the outrage and sweep it under the rug. Itā€™s not that they canā€™t compensate players. They wonā€™t.

Itā€™s absolutely ridiculous. This doesnā€™t come from some misplaced sense of entitlement. This is setting a very, very dangerous precedent. Anything you do in-game, can be lost or taken away without any sort of compensation. Blizzard donā€™t value the progress youā€™re making. The bigger question is, why should you?

4 Likes

Would you like to expand on what youā€™re saying?

Are you asking us why should we care about the progress weā€™re making? or stating by means of a rhetorical question that we shouldnā€™t care, and we should just forgive and forget?

1 Like

It also being on the 20th anniversary that gives that extra sting.

Blizzard still has time to make it right for me, I have cancelled my sub but it will take a few months to run out.

BUT

If they do make it right, this will really be the last time they can treat me like this.
Some of us have gone through the whole dead server issue: being ignored, not given a solution and seeing the classic servers getting thrown free transfers at them.

So its: last chance or its me gone for good and that is gone for good from anything Blizzard releases. Tbh, they probably prefer having me gone.

7 Likes

Players from China will receive an additional 500 Trade Tokens per year.
And why do they need us, with our endless problems? Blizzard has someone to take care of.

I had a lot of pets and mats, including a lot of unobtainable now Accursed Keepsake.

I have received nothing in my e-mail, does anyone know if itā€™s still in progress or itā€™s final that I will get completely nothing?

3 Likes

No, no one knows unfortunately. Not even the support staff because they give conflicting information every other day.

Iā€™m in the same boat as you, my entire guild bank was wiped out and so far I have had nothing mailed to me.

3 Likes