Tirei would want to go to the pandaren afterlife THAT VERY MUCH EXISTS THANK YOU but I am afraid she’d be sent to Bastion instead because of who she is.
With Kaiyu, probably the pandaren afterlife, but possibly Ardenweald depending on the more specific requirements (so far we only have a vague ‘serve nature’)
Nothing you just cited actually conflicts with what I’m telling you my guy
I’ll find the quest for you later when I’m back at my PC
My troll girl would probably go to Ardenweald, hopefully she would meet Rhunok’s spirit there and could help tend to him before his rebirth - Bonwa’su would probably end up as one of the animal spirits there - a bear - and help out the caretakers.
Itzama’tul here would 100% go to Bastion. He is all about his duty to Zandalar above all else. Though he could possibly have an issue with the whole “Forget your past!” deal and be sent to another afterlife were things to go sour.
Wherever regular night elves go. Probably not any of the main ones, unless all night elves go to Ardenweald or something. Lintian probably wouldn’t be happy in Ardenweald if this were the case.
Maldraxxus, simple as
Ardenweald 1000%.
I honestly can’t decide. All 4 of the realms feel a little too black and white to choose from. Ouren isn’t a bad soul but she sure has regrets for deeds past. Perhaps there are other realms beyond the veil lost through the ages. (I personally hope)
Ardenweald feels too nature-y even though I would have liked somewhere with similar aesthetic for Ouren but it doesn’t feel correct for her to belong there. I guess Revendreth/Bastion is next “best” thing?
https://wow.gamepedia.com/Ritual_of_Judgment
here you go
All sinful souls have a chance to be condemned to the Maw by the Venthyr if they’re unwilling or unable to be redeemed.
there are literally infinite afterlives. Blizz has confirmed this a few times, and also stated a new one is made to suit souls that don’t quite belong to any.
Oh that’s good news! Thanks for pointing that out.
Only those initially sent to Revendreth.
Which… all sinful souls do, unless specific exceptions are made, like how Draka got plucked out of the threads of fate to go help out in Maldraxxus.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-Q67Upjq7H8
19:40 onwards
“Precious few souls, over the eons, the Arbiter would send directly into the Maw”.
So, no.
Galford would go to maldraxxus because he can hang out with the cooler of the two paladin legends in shadowlands
Where Is Lythalnis is in Maldraxxus. Few years actually. The impostor has her place in Azeroth. She ran through House of Eyes and then after it’s fall to the House of Chosen now defending Seat of Primus from the Traitors.
My rogue would go to Revendreth due to how much sin she commits.
Druid, obiviously goes to Ardenweald.
I don’t think you realize that you’re agreeing with me here.
Slow down, life is to be savoured.
Good shout! I didn’t think about this one.
My warrior would probably stay with the Maldraxxi (I forgot their covenant name).
My warlock would go to both Revendreth and join the Venthyr, having lived a life of sin and excess.
Really, because it seems like you backpeddled from this:
So I’m glad we could come to a middle ground, since your initial statement was incorrect. 
it’s still correct as a rule so idk what your gotcha is.
Of course there’s exceptions, I didn’t think I’d need to add that as a disclaimer.
Can we please take the lore talk out of this thread? There’s plenty others talking about the lore of Shadowlands, this thread isn’t one of them.
I appreciate the engagement, but it’s derailing from the thread topic.