Since DF guardian were nerfed so bad that they become useless in all PvP aspects, while you cannot kill a similarly pvp geared player (impossible due to the low damage) and still get killed by them once you run out of CDs, pvp classes which use magical attacks were able to bring a pvp tank in matter of seconds since the class had low defence against magical attacks, our only hopes were to find a newbie pvp player who still have no pvp gears to land your first kill. most of guardian player left the class due to Blizzard developers ignored this class while made playable only in PVE.
The official pvp leadboards showed the Guardian class scoring the lowest rating in all aspects of pvp, end game gears become unobtainable for this class. until end of expansion where few players which you can count by hand from the whole world (6-8 players) were able to hit over 2k with luck and getting carried by other classes.
this lead me and many other players to stop playing wow.
With the coming of RBG we hoped blizzard owned now by MS will rethink their strategy and bring the guardian back to their feet, after 2 years of break from wow and the launch of WW i activated my subscription and came back to the game hoping RBG will make the class playable in PVP.
Well guess what, they made Guardian a GOD in PVE. between each boss, I can pull the whole instance mobs with the boss it self in heroic and require 0 heal from a healer, i can self heal and let the dps do the kills. But in PVP Guardian does no damage and cant even self heal , with 4000k HP outside of bear form can pop HP to 8000k in bear form, Guardian cant even land a single kill on a 2000k hp super low geared player, you cant self heal or reduce the damage taken, you cant bring the player HP less than 80%, the tank get killed both in pvp word and BGs by any low ungeared player.
Now the big fun start, similarly geared player or even a bit less geared, a Guardian cannot bring their health down 100% due to their self defence and heals, dps are tankier than a Guardian, you will not stay alive after the 1st 30 seconds of popping all your strong defence CDs and Self heal, you will have to spend all your rage in Ironfur and FR to bring your HP back Guardian of Ursoc is active, still you cannot full heal due to the strong damage you are receiving and cannot dps since u need to keep spamming Ironfur and FR to stay alive. Once Guardian of Ursoc then congratulation, you survived 30 sec and now count 3 seconds to find your self at the nearest GY.
This class is really broken, useless and certainly become stressing and depressing to play, a new tree that provide 0 damage and 0 defence in PVP, a talent called Light of Elune that procs one a day.
Time lo cancel the subscription and leave this game again, maybe in 2050 when the actual developers retire and you have new one who actually play the game we may see some changes.