Raid Encounter Design in Season 3

Last week we made several adjustments to The Venomous Abyss with the intent of reducing the number of damage events that could kill you or your entire raid with a single individual mistake. We believe this type of severe mechanical penalty was used too often in The Venomous Abyss, causing the associated mechanics to become frustrating as the season wore on. Our goal with these changes was to ensure that damage events feel more proportional to player mistakes and to reduce the number of instances where individual mistakes could easily trigger group wipes. A couple examples from that list of changes:

  • Malice damage was reduced by 45% on Mythic and 63% on Normal/Heroic, which should now help a failed interrupt feel like a punishing but recoverable group mistake.
  • Reductions to Noxious Splash’s initial damage (33%) and damage-over-time component (84%) should help ensure that a single individual’s mistake no longer feels like a death sentence.

We feel that our design has shifted over time at the expense of the average Mythic player’s experience. Going forward into Season 3, we’d like to intentionally pull back on some of these severe mechanical penalties, even at the start of the season. Once Season 3 launches on the Public Test Realm, we’d like to invite you to test each difficulty of the new raid and see for yourselves.

What is a “mechanical penalty”?
Generally, when an encounter designer creates a mechanic, they also design a corresponding penalty to reinforce the gameplay that the mechanic is intended to incentivize.

Sometimes this can be very simple. If an add spawns in the encounter and the tank doesn’t establish threat on it quickly, it can melee and endanger other players. The tank needs to pick that add up quickly, which is hopefully fun gameplay for the tank. That’s pretty straightforward.

Other times, these penalties can be complex. Let’s use Heroic Ula’tek as an example. If enough individual players don’t contribute to soaking Stone Venom, a player will be affected by Calcified Corpse and very likely wipe the raid. Players need to split into roughly equal groups, react quickly, and ensure that they’re staying with their assigned player until the Stone Venom aura has expired. Calcified Corpse exists only to reinforce gameplay that we want players to enjoy in that phase.

“The Punishment Must Fit the Crime”
When we design mechanics and their corresponding penalties, it’s important for them to be proportional to each other. For example, a small missile landing on a character should generally not kill an appropriately geared character from 100% HP. However, if every player in the raid collectively ignores Malacrass’ cast of Eternal Nightfall, he will eventually complete his cast and destroy the raid.

When mechanics and their penalties are out of proportion, a sense of frustration usually sets in. This threshold (what feels “unfair”) can be very different from player to player, and we spend a lot of time internally discussing what will feel right for each raid difficulty.

We’ve heard a lot of player feedback about this element of raid difficulty. Going forward, we want to be more lenient in places where we’ve previously killed players in a single damage event or quickly wiped the raid as a result of a single point of failure. Our hope is to retain the challenge and sense of achievement you feel from completing encounters - but allow for more satisfying progression along the way. Fewer wipes that feel like “instant death” and more wipes that feel like a slow unraveling as the group makes mistakes and productively learns from them.

Again, we invite you to join us on the Season 3 PTR once it begins. Please join us for raid testing and let us know your thoughts.

You said this exact same thing for the first time in Shadowlands during Sepulcher, stop repeating the same mistake over and over again.

1 Like

Thing is, apart from seed-into-instant-kill mechanics, I loved how a lot of the mechanics in Venomous Abyss worked. But… that doesn’t mean I loved how punishing they were.

I feel like there would have been less dislike and disfavour overall of the raid if it was just… a bit more lenient.

I understand it is much more painful on a Mythic difficulty setting however, after hearing that you not only have to deal with ghosts on Coiled Altar, but also the fact they were invisible and cannot touch each other…

Seen this exact sentiment laid out to us before, with Shadowlands. And yet, here we are again.
Instead of telling us players this, you should be communicating this loud and clear to your own design team, because it seems they are the ones not on page with what was previously already declared to us.

It doesn’t seem like you have any senior encounter designer on your team who oversees the principles of raid design & design philosophy. If anything it sounds more like you just let the encounter designers do whatever they like, something that is supported by the stuff those very designers have said in a few interviews recently. Having absolute freedom without a proper guiding hand is not a great idea when the audience in questions is hundreds of thousands of players across the world.

The issue with venomous abyss is that some of the challenging mechanics are more suited to a Solo-player boss fight, like a mage tower, more than in a 20-man raid team, & that is a trend on most bosses in this raid. I personally like a majority of the mechanics, but that’s only because I have the confidence of executing them well. What made me hate the raid despite what I just said, was that I would need to put up with 19 others also needing to get on that same page, which is just not good design, it leads to only frustrating experiences every raid night.

I hope whatever you change now philosophically for 12.2’s raid is carved in stone, so your designers know and respect the limits, so every future raid tier after that does not revert back to the unfun experience that is the Venomous Abyss.

Mythic raiding in wow should just be this :-
Every boss has mechanics that can be achieved by 3-5 players at max doing things a certain way, but if they fail, it hurts the raid and yet can still be recovered with better play.

Every guild should only require 4-5 excellent players who are great at dealing with very challenging pass/fail mechanics, mechanics/gimmicks speciifc to mythic mode, while the rest of the group contributes in their own way whilst playing regular mechanics. I say this because this is the reality of the make-up of most Mythic guilds out there from a player skill level.
Do not confuse this with Lu’ra crytals, or Fyrak seeds though, failing their mechanics should not cause an instant wipe, as mentioned previously, a pull should always feel recoverable unless a lot of players die.

1 Like

If enough individual players don’t contribute to soaking Stone Venom, a player will be affected by Calcified Corpse and very likely wipe the raid. Players need to split into roughly equal groups, react quickly, and ensure that they’re staying with their assigned player until the Stone Venom aura has expired.

Stone Venom is the tank DOT. You are thinking of Serpent’s Bite.

welcome back, everyone.
i know it’s been like two years, since we last had a revelation like this, but finally the current designteam has caught up.
I wish to take this opportunity to express my condolences for you guys losing or quitting your jobs in the near future, so the next set of junior devs can learn the same lessons all over again

This will not solve the issue. You have promised that over and over again and from a customer perspective it just looks like you guys don’t write stuff like that down where your devs can read it.

You said so in shadowlands and failed again in dragonflight.

The first goal for any content should be fun the challenge can be second (if at all). If people want to generate a challenge, they can already do so. RWF is such a challenge. By limiting the amount of time and being competitive, they already created their own challenge.

Designe and tune the encounters on your end-target/goal and focus your time and effort into delivering bug free patches and updates. Each class discord has a known bugs section and some of those have been around since TWW. Can you please turn to fixing what you already have?

We already did provide an abundance of feedback on the ptr and next to all of it got ignored. We already communicate our wishes. I just don’t feel like you communicate your actual targets. If you want the seed mechanic to be in every CE-Endboss going forward, please upload a video were your internal raid testing team can accomplish that fight without any add-ons. I would really like to see how it is done.

Reading this, it sounds incredibly promising as if they’ve finally realized what’s wrong/or what could be improved and better times are on the horizon.
Unfortunately, Blizzard is just using new words for the same old lies and excuses.

simple questions:
Were the raid mechanics difficult? No!
Were the raid mechanics (extremely) annoying or poorly balanced for small groups? YES!
The “problems” mentioned above have gone hand-in-hand for a very long time. While it’s extremely difficult to satisfy everyone, it’s also, in a way, quite simple. The issue is that Blizzard is incredibly stubborn regarding many of their decisions and stuck in their old ways.

Many of us surely remember Shadowlands Season 4, where raid affixes were activated via a console before each boss an experience that some might have found interesting, while others perhaps did not.
However, that very concept could actually help with balancing future raids. Currently, Normal difficulty is too easy, Heroic acts somewhat like a filter, while Mythic is truly reserved for dedicated raiders (though this varies from boss to boss and season to season I trust everyone understands what I mean).

However, if we were to treat boss abilities as “affixes” allowing them to be freely added or removed via the console it would open the door to an entirely new world.
Without going into too much detail, just imagine this:
The more abilities (affixes) a boss has, the more the dropped items are “upgraded” (e.g., 3/6, 5/6, 6/6, or even 9/6, including items from the bonus loot—with 9/6 applying to Myth-quality items on the Myth difficulty only). This would also scale the quantity of loot (for example, 10 players receiving 4 items instead of the current 2).
And it would be the exact opposite when it comes to reducing abilities: lower item upgrades, or even the complete removal of loot including the chance for bonus loot. Of course, there’s still the Vault; in there, a significantly weakened boss might be classified as Normal, even if you were playing on Heroic. (Nothing in this world is free if you want things to be too easy don’t raid at all.)
If anyone is worried that having too many abilities would make things confusing simply put, there’s no need to add that many new abilities (if any at all). After all, each difficulty already slightly alters how an ability behaves, how many players are targeted by it, or how many people are required to survive it.
For example, consider the “Lost Explorers” encounter:
On HC/M All 3 turtles could be together, Gebbo’s bomb wouldn’t leave behind a zone of fire or a debuff from the wave, mushrooms wouldn’t disappear after use, each boss would use their ultimate ability 3-more times instead of 2, and many other things could be easily tweaked yet such changes could completely alter the difficulty.
Naturally, the console for Mythic difficulty should only become accessible after the the boss is defeated for 1st time or once the season reaches its midpoint.

Obviously, the simplest way to make the raid easier without having to change too much would be to lift (or completely remove) the restrictions on addons. The season is already well underway, yet people still don’t understand how to place the orbs during the Sszorak encounter it’s not just sad or funny it’s absolute stupidity. Of course, Blizzard is also to blame even after 20+ years, they haven’t managed to add a simple video tutorial to the game explaining how to handle specific abilities. Sure, it’s incredibly easy to watch a video on YouTube or check Mythic Trap, so a lack of knowledge regarding tactics or mechanics is mostly just laziness. But if you’re asking whether such a feature is actually necessary well, just look up someone playing WoW for the first time on YouTube once you see how poor the tutorial for new players is, you’ll have your answer.

However, since add-ons are a highly contentious topic with both very strong support and strong opposition it is impossible to satisfy everyone. This leads to a simple question. if Blizzard is willing to maintain a Hardcore version of the game which has a player base of only a few tens of thousands compared to the standard version why haven’t they released a version let’s call it “Retail-A” with A as Add-ons (yes very original name right? :D) where add-ons function exactly as they did before the release of TWW?
Wouldn’t this satisfy both sides? And I believe the number of people who would want the add-ons back wouldn’t just be a few tens of thousands.

Dear Blizzard,
To understand which part of the WoW community you are getting the feedback from, let me talk a little bit about myself. I have been playing this game for as long as the first raid starter in WoW. I started as a hardcore player and, slowly, with age and the game’s lifespan, I became what you call a semi-hardcore player. We clear Mythic; we do all the content, but at our own pace (700-1000). Not a chad gamer anymore, right? But we still bring passion to the game to get the job done.

What is my experience playing with better and worse players on the highest difficulty? Frustrating. You may have 15 awesome players, but there is always someone with slower reaction time, worse ping, or lower FPS who will wipe you instantly. If the encounters didn’t take 10 min to play and wipe within 1 sec, it wouldn’t be that annoying. Failing the mechanic and adapting to the fail - either with higher DPS or bigger HPS would be fine, but NOT instantly killing everyone.

A few examples:

  • Ula’tek Eggs and waves: you don’t always have mages or locks to make the waves easier, yet people still fail that. The part about colliding, I think, is valid tho!
    • Viper spawn from Egg carrier hit by wave (yes, they were reduced, lol!) in 80% of situations was a wipe if unlucky with who that add targets
    • Two egg people colliding, wipe as two Vipers and -2 people is not something you can get out of
    • Stacking within millimeters while under first bubble (add) into another wipe could be missed. The visual was poor while stacked.
  • Altar had two adds which required people to stack the debuffs on top and react to the randomness of spawn while others were panic-running away, and on TOP of that, making sure your ghost does not move while others could not see it, so couldn’t help to clear the path.
    • Colliding ghost, wipe usually (-2)
    • Not hitting the add with two debuffs, wipe
    • Interrupt fail, wipe
  • Again, eggs, but this time Midnight Falls, same principle. You get hit, wipe

All mechanics that instantly wipe your raid and give you no room for overcoming the mistakes are the worst idea ever made. Don’t try to get us engaged in the fight by adding such 1 fail, full-wipe designs, as you are creating a situation where you have to get annoyed, pissed, and get into a blame game against that one player who… didn’t listen. Most of the guilds these days don’t have a huge bench of players that can be stepping in and replacing the weakest. It is no longer possible with 20-man raiding (don’t get me started that Flex should be the only choice for the future). I can’t just say, ‘X, you are wiping us; let’s play with 19’. There is nothing worst then the feeling of wiping because of that one or 2-3 people who just are slower to adapt. You can be a god of DPS, HPS, or tanking, but if that one person fails (even due to lag), it is yet another 5-8min lost.

Most of the time, it is not progression you do; it is grinding till they don’t get the mechanic that can instantly wipe you.

1 Like

Of course, sure, whatever…

Cannot do much when the game director has a memory lasting less than a season.

1 Like