I didn’t speak about entitlement, what exactly are you trying to do here by twisting my words?
I appreciate the charity you’ve given in constructively looking at my stances/posts (even if I haven’t directly responded, seeing the heavy dogpile made me decide to make a brief, broad answer instead). I may return later (when work is done) and respond more directly, as I don’t want to blank the honest exchange.
The wonders of democracy, Loras. Where my beliefs are just as legitimate as yours. Our stances are both welcomed, entertained, legal and involved in discussion. Such is the law and foundation of our society.
Yeah there’s a reason why I ate a week’s ban for insulting them recently. This isn’t the thread for me to further air my grievances, but I think it’s absolutely tragic to see this person go from somebody I would happily call a friend to someone who both treats every topic with sheer indifference while maintaining a “holier-than-thou” mentality.
Political allignments rarely indicate if a person is kind or cruel, dumb or smart, and certainly don’t indicate right or wrong. It’s the reasons the person leans towards those alignments that can indicate that IMO.
But of course that can’t be the case, nuance can’t be had. There’s only the Good Party (mine) and the Bad Party (yours).
Lame. Boring. Your political allignments aren’t a sports team to cheer on.
No, you’re clearly part of the conspiracy, and a brigade in the total war of crypto-fascism as you sit in my discord and projects, Obahar. We need to reroll new alts again. [Sarcasm]
The wonders of democracy, Loras. Where my beliefs are just as legitimate as yours. Our stances are both welcomed, entertained, legal and involved in discussion. Such is the law and foundation of our society.
bro is doing another classic bit from the playbook
I didn’t speak about entitlement, what exactly are you trying to do here by twisting my words?
I am not trying to twist your words or make you look bad. I am simply interpreting what you wrote above:
if you get a feeling that a machine - made for regurgitating and replicating a very primitive slice of “median high quality digital art” - is treading on your ground, that’s a point to reflect on - maybe there is some complacency and stagnation in the field (there is - there always is).
Have you considered that I am just quoting you without any ill-will?
I however don’t feel the need for vague-posting and backhanded theorizing about intent, beliefs etc.
I don’t think you have nefarious plans about this whole thing. It’s largely that your own takes in the thread have been in many parts vague while simultaneously slandering certain groups of people that it has probably left some people - myself included - wondering if it’s worthwhile to continue direct dialogue with someone who doesn’t seem as eager to discuss the issues of the AI image generators as they seem to make unkind remarks about other people or their posts. But if you’re willing to clarify, be our guest:
Another “profession” challenged by technology
What exactly do you mean by “profession” ? What did you wish to contribute to the thread with this post?
I just find it extremely ironic to see people losing it over AI generated art and arguing pseudo-labour and worker’s rhetoric, (but as others have pointed out, just as I have in past iterations of these same-y threads) did not make a fuss about automation in other sectors. Not until said automation threatened their cozy cultural monopoly.
Who are these people? Are they in this thread? Is it really ironic given where we’re discussing this topic?
cozy cultural monopoly.
This comes across as a sarcastic way saying that artists have an exclusive possession or control of the supply of their trade. Did you intend it to be interpreted this way?
The elitism is this very thread, and each predecessor. The elitism of the Bohemian-escue mentality of modern “artists” is an insult to actual working class people, and those that dedicate to labor-value.
Could you provide some examples of such elitistic takes in this thread that are an insult to actual working class people?
A clique of people that think charging 50€ for 10 minutes of scuff is somehow owed and deserved, and then lose their minds when AI generation comes around. Laziness. Entitlement. This thread and past threads have been littered with pseudo-workerist talking points, which is once again an insult to actual working class people.
I haven’t seen people in this thread rooting for charging 50€ for 10 minutes of scuff or similar, are you referring to people here or elsewhere? And again could you provide some examples of those pseudo-workerist talking points people have posted here that you view as an insult to working class people?
Just someone fed up with the entitlement of modern “artists”.
Which is not even to touch upon the absolute filth and toxicity of the “art community”, their behavior, their cutthroat sabotaging and backstabbing, the entire mess that is that sickly place.
Who exactly do you mean by “artists” and the “art community”? What has led to you having such a poor opinion of them?
- Socially/Culturally hard-right, traditional Catholic
- Economically far-left, working-class populist
- State absolutist (the polar opposite of any libertarian tech bro out there as was implied prior)
- Nordic/Scandinavian
Just a nordic tankie then
Opinion discarded
bro is doing another classic bit from the playbook
True – and I don’t especially feel the need to mind my manners, when the socially/politically “hard” right would deny me the right to exist as a queer/trans person.
Intersectionality between artists and queer people is also a very big thing, come to think of it.
The moral high horse is wooden.
Have you considered that I am just quoting you without any ill-will?
E.g.,“if a machine made to replicate a “median high quality digital art” style is producing results very close to what we are doing - maybe we’ve all collectively been doing too similar things and it’s a good time to mix stuff up” - due to how data is collected and reprocessed by AI, it can be viewed as kind of a warped mirror onto today’s digital art and various interesting observations made.
It’s not a “now compete with the machine, else it’s entitlement” argument and I’m not lending AI any legitimacy there. If you quote me, quote the exact words.
bro is doing another classic bit from the playbook
You do your tribe proud.
Just a nordic tankie then
Opinion discarded
Not a tankie neither. In the wide sphere with some beliefs, but not a tankie.
True – and I don’t especially feel the need to mind my manners, when the socially/politically “hard” right would deny me the right to exist as a queer/trans person.
Don’t even try. Your petty tribalism and prepared victim-complex is disgusting. Obahar really has pinned you rightly so many times.
I’ve been put on the stand for this exact boogeyman made-up argument before in these same very threads.
God created you, just like he created me. God loves you just as he loves me. We are all equal before Him. No one is better than the other, and we’ll all be judged equally. You’ve free will, just like me. You have a right to exist just as I do. We are equal. I don’t have the right (legally nor per Scripture) to hurt you, nor “deny your right to exist”. I stick to myself, I live my own life, and could not care less about others as I am only in charge of my own salvation and choices/actions in the end. Whether I morally agree with another person is a different story, but God will be the judge in the end, not me.
Do not pin the deeds of extremist Protestants and whacko’s out on line with my religion and the Holy Mother Church on my shoulders. Disgusting.
Wow… He really went there.
when jesus comes back he’ll be so pissed off with you guys
I was raised Catholic and attended Catholic primary and secondary schools, I am aware of its behaviours. A socially/politically right-wing person will vote for people with corresponding beliefs, who will then push for those harmful policies that would render me mentally unwell rather than self-identifying.
(edited this post instead of making a new comment accidentally)
Wow… He really went there.
Don’t try to grandstand with your “battery acid” post history.
I was raised Catholic and attended Catholic primary and secondary schools, I am aware of its behaviours. A socially/politically right-wing person will vote for people with corresponding beliefs, who will then push for those harmful policies that would render me mentally unwell rather than self-identifying.
I am a single-issue voter. I voted for the progressive/leftist party in past elections (Swedish People’s Party, Finland)
Take your own advice.
If you quote me, quote the exact words.
I do not have access to a time machine to be able to tell what you meant in the future, Emberblast. I took your initial post as stating that if you feel threathened by an AI (untrained on other people’s art, mind you), then maybe it is indeed a time to try something else or improve.
Maybe you should have written this post instead of your former one initially instead?
Don’t forget the general tone of attempting to divide people. Hate the brown or poor and deport the foreign.
My general point was that it’s not something you can shove off onto the Protestant section of Christianity because Catholicism is equally culpable, but I do respect your priorities in being pro-worker more than pro-conservatism.
My general point was that it’s not something you can shove off onto the Protestant section of Christianity because Catholicism is equally culpable
I very much can, and I very much am. For what was discussed (unlike what I wrote) is not part of our singular, traditional, non-interpretation based faith. Such is the way, as you should know as someone raised Catholic. Neither the Pontiff, nor the Church agrees with your claims.
but I do respect your priorities in being pro-worker more than pro-conservatism.
Your “respect” is useless to me, seeing how you’ve hammered me, vague-posted me, spun wild theories and backhanded suspicions about me, and then try to fence-ride and sass me thereafter. Be better, God bless.
stating that if you feel threathened by an AI (untrained on other people’s art, mind you), then maybe it is indeed a time to try something else or improve.
It is, but nowhere it states that “otherwise it’s entitlement” or that the AI is somehow justified in pushing you out. Let’s split the blame between my wording skills and your reading comprehension.
Also,
an AI (untrained on other people’s art, mind you)
Within the context of what we’re talking about (generative AI for images) they don’t exist, so I dunno where that came from.