I see some people here posting that it would be hard to balance the three sets for each class… I presume thoughts coming from their rich game-design experience.
Here’s my two cents.
Set balancing can put close to no workload on the Blizz team.
Historically, the Blizz team has always been more concerned with the 0.1% of top players playing this game, and balancing it only for them. The rest of us, who do not like to go above M+20 are forced to play around a meta set by people who play this game like it’s their job (and for some of them, it maybe is). Balancing this game for the top 0.1% sure is a nightmare, I am certain this requires a lot of simulations and brain-power invested into balance from the design team. But do we need that?
So let’s presume that for Season 4, we have all DF Sets to choose from. I foresee that:
- All sets will be simmed by the community before the patch even gets released.
- Popular community websites will release a ‘Tier set ranklist’ based on sims.
- Part of the community will go for the set that enables them to play a certain build.
- The majority of the community will go for the top1 set from those ranklists.
- The 0.1% of players will go for the best set/build.
Clearly, some sets would be left behind in a ‘B’, ‘C’, ‘D’ tier. Blizz would only need to do a slight touch and buff them 5/10/15/20/100% and let the community sim them again. Rinse and repeat until all sets are in an ‘acceptable’ level (I don’t mean 100% balanced, just ‘good enough’). It’s not like you see any ‘B’ tier classes in the rio top100 mythic list.
Obviously I am very pro-give-us-all-three-sets. For some reason I kinda expected that to happen for Season 4, and was left a bit shocked that we’re doing this weird forums voting instead.
For me it’s a no-brainer… Seasons 1 to 3 introduced sets that clearly favored certain class play-styles. Something like Blizz saying “In this season, I want you to switch your build to this one”, which… is questionable, but I get it. It would be 100% acceptable if players still had the choice to not switch to the new set. Which is why I was certain that in season 4, I would not be forced to play the same playstyle from season 3.
Example - I have not played my shaman at all in season 3, since I hate the primordial wave playstyle, I like the Lightning one a lot. I kinda want to play my shaman, but when I log it in and see Primordial Wave, I immediately lose motivation and switch to something I like.
I implore Blizz to use the experience they gained from Diablo3 (remember how in most of the early seasons, only one class set would dominate the leaderboards) and give players variation. This is the same “I don’t want to play the boring Hammer of the Ancients barbarian if I want to climb higher rifts” problem, now moved in WoW, like it never happened in D3.