I’ve simmed it now at 272ilvl and 259.
For 259 it’s a wash… about the same dps.
https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/cvsGRSKaCf6N7ch1qX683P
For 272 i’d get about 579 dps.
https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/na9hWNSqHgV6Za5eXqcs32
Though i’m reluctant since i’d lose a ton of haste… which is important for taking advantage of the 2 piece set, at 4 sec now with enough haste i can fit in 2 finishers 90%+ of the time.
The sims can’t really account for that, since it sometimes takes timing from the player while watching the swing timer.
It’s a bit bigger when using only 1 2hander i guess.
If i’ll ever get it i’ll test it out.
But after how much luck i had getting Old Warrior’s Soul trinket last tier… i won’t hold my breath. (says 1.5% drop rate for the gavel on wowhead… lol)