Ofc tanks turn into dps, and healers swap aswell, everyone does. Why would a new tank spec somehow lower the amount tanks because of that? Surely this only adds to my point that people actually might swap to the shaman tank if available.
You said that I mentioned players that you don’t know, remember that? Now you’re doing the exact same thing;
Just because DK, monk and DH tanks did not improve it does not mean that a new tank wont either. Like I said before, people choose specs based on different things. Take this as an example; I like tanking the most, yet I only wanna play prot warr currently, because I dislike the other tanks. If prot warr did not exist, I wouldn’t get to play my favorite role. If shaman tank exists, maybe someone will go “finally I can play a fun tank”. You don’t know that, stop acting like you.
You said that the abilities that tanks share with their class dps specs shouldn’t count in your evaluation. This is what I am pointing at. Again you are avoiding me, you’re avoiding everything important constantly.
Never ever did I say that prot warr has the same healing as blood dk, I just said they have a lot and can keep themselves up well. Then you said that thing about “they’re ALL accessible by dps” as if that somehow matters? Why would it matter what the dps specs can do when evaluating what the tank can do? Makes no sense. All of the specs accessibilities should be included when evaluating how they perform.
I never argued against that some tanks have more or less dmg mitigation and self healing than others.
[quote=“Uda-uldum, post:57, topic:504768”]
And for the record : Other druid specs share Bear Form. But only GDruid has Ursine Adept passive talent, PLUS, a whole talent tree that depends on being in Bear Form and that has positive feedback loops with it.
I poked holes in your theory completely, how can you not notice that?
And misquoting me like this is really foul of you. I have never said anything even close to this. It’s extremely bad behavior in a conversation to misrepresent someone that bad.
First off, I never nagged, but nice word choice. Second, I never conceded my point and just because other people thought like you did doesn’t mean they’re right. Quantity does not equal truth. But if it did we would be even since there were people agreeing with me aswell. So stop making things up.