I mean i agree with u, everywhere u look, and a prime example of this is Asmongold. While he does say “I have other things i want to do” as a reason for not playing wow, we all know hed no life it just like he has if the game was “ACTUALLY GOOD”. Why hes so popular and became so big is because he in someway represents a lot of wow players, and somewhat how we feel. Atleast the CORE players that used to play wow no matter what. When people as die hard as him, says “dragonflight is good” meanwhile doesnt touch it after the first 2 weeks, i feel like the words lack any meaning. WE ALL KNOW, if Arthas was brought back and they retconned everything, and went a different direction, hed be back no lifing it for a few more years.
Not to say that asmon is the only example of this. Bellular has been making videos for ages i watched him in WOD a lot, his tone this expansion has felt like “wow is good, this might be the thing that makes it do well in the future, it comes off more as copium than anything else”. When u need to make up excuses as to why u should play wow nowadays thats a pretty obvious disclaimer as to why u shouldnt.
Im the same way, i cant put my finger on what exactly, ive played since Wotlk. I had periods where i was burnt out and just left and then came back. I played for like a year then quit for like 2 years or smthn then it repeated etc. But i came back at the end of shadowlands and had a lot of fun even though i understood the issues of SL. I was excited to play wow again, DF around the corner, and i nolifed wotlk classic release. After 2 months of DF i started playing Hardcore which game me more positive vibes than retail did. Which is VEEEERY strange. I never liked leveling, but somehow i enjoy leveling in classic because it felt like it mattered. I felt rewarded. As soon as official servers were announced i quit because i knew all i did on that character would be obselete the second the servers come out.
I pretty sure the majority of players agree on this, why play if ure not rewarded?
Would anyone play league if Ranked wasnt a thing?
U dont have to make the game omega casuals for players to invest into wow, u just have to make it good and very cool. In league u have to level to 30 to do ranked, yet thousands if not millions of people do it even tho its anoying af, because they know the reward is being able to play ranked later on and feel rewarded when u reach a new milestone.
Stop coping that most people dont play to be rewarded its not true. Look at all the big games rn, the most popular ones are the rewarding games. People play CSGO because its fun simple, but hard to master, and yet u have the carrot of if u actually get good enough u might actually be able to make a living off it. Wether it be a pro player, or playing the market with skins to fininacially better ur life. Theres incentive to doing things.