Guardian Druid vs Protection Paladin

[Holyprotect-twisting-nether]

Who is better in your opinion?
xD

[Uvi-tirion (Uvi)]

Better for what?

In any case I would say Protpala, since Guardiandruid is about as much fun as watching paint dry.

[Holyprotect-twisting-nether]

general tanking

[Gatherix-tarren-mill (Gatherix)]

Leveling, WQs and other daily BS -> Druid (has a lot of utility like stealth, travel forms, faster indoor running speed in cat form, etc)

Raiding and Dungeon -> Paladin

[Tpaartas-aegwynn]

Guardian druid with mage tower skin > Prot Paladin
Guardian druid without mage tower skin < Prot Paladin

[Chronormi-outland]

Draenei can’t be druids so paladin.

[Haldjier-blackmoore]

Guardian Druid with Ursocs Fury legendary 10/10. Pull the whole room and gain insane shield. I dont know many other tanks but compared to DH it is more fun to me. In Raid i can play off spec cat or moonkin todo damage. This is not a boring spec. :). In PVP as flag carry is also nice.

I dont play high m+ keys so dont know if it sucks in that content

[Verdill-burning-legion (Verdill)]

@Uvi-tirion

watching paint dry

Stupid comparison. Drying paint has more depth

[Daestra-turalyon]

@Holyprotect-twisting-nether

Who is better in your opinion?

I have both tanks i enjoy both of them very much since TBC ,i think they both have good pro’s and con’s and both can tank at a very good level you got to play what YOU enjoy and stop worrying what others think .

@Verdill-burning-legion

Off topic your mog is really nice

[anon35582437]

very vague question, both have their perks and drawbacks, purely from a tanking / meta perspective i think prot is better atm.

However if you care less about being top tank out of all tanks, druid definitely has some cool stuff

[Uranüs-argent-dawn]

Moooooo. Nothing beats a bear with horns

[Raijin-earthen-ring]

Guardian is the tankier tank. Playing this spec is probably the worst experience you can subject yourself to in Warcraft though.