Considering that us superior priests have a higher base stat of both strength and agility than the other two scrub casters I’m pretty confident that my brothers and sisters would dumpster the competition in a brawl.
If nothing but melee allowed then disc priests with that - 20% dmg inner fire thing buff.
If heals are allowed on top of melee, priests.
If fire armor mage with high crit, mage (heals disabled)
If warlock can use drain life/pet? Then lock . (heals disabled fel hunter dispels the fire shield)
The warlock would wave around its puny sword, the mage would swing his wand and the priest would smash their skulls with its 40kg steel bound spellbook he has been carrying since he was 5yo.
Depends on what but realistically speaking I don’t think anyone can punch a warlock to death as a caster unless corruptions had anything to say about it. the passives demon armor and soul leech are pretty gross
If no passives you have to acivate, spells or abilities, lock wins as their stamina base is vastly higher than the other two, much greater than the different in base strength between them. Not to mention soul leech keeps them going and you can’t turn it off.
If spells are allowed, well it’s not a melee fight then is it?
Boralus mage vs Orc mage in melee, would that make any sense?
both are beefed up people but they only use magic as their arsenal.
Like for guldan, he is a orc but isn’t strong when it comes to hand to hand combat.
its like having two wwe wrestlers who took the path of reading books and learn magic and than suddenly go in, with regular punches and whacks with staffs.