In any way it’s an original idea, you have it in Overwatch (and in FF XIV if you look for a MMO example).
Idea is simple. You finish dungeon, and give some player a commendation.
Commendation = cool rewards (mounts, transmogs, titles, achievements).
Why it isn’t implemented in WoW?
A mount for completing a dungeon? I mean, isn’t that a little too much?
I like it in lineage 2.
the healers and tanks would get them all at least thats how i give them in ff 14 
also you would need over 500 commendations for anything cool anyway so that’s 500+ dungeons assuming only one party member per dungeon gave you one per run since you cannot give one to a pre made party member
sounds good doesnt work, you will get the same thing as play of the game in games like overwatch or league of legends. The only ones who really will profit from this are premades who are constantly upvoting their friends and because that always ending up with the most votes
you can’t vote your friend in FF14’s system though premades cannot vote for etc other the voting is completely disabled if you enter the que with nothing but pre made members you can only vote for a friend if they que’ed alone and you just happen to be in the same party
It would be abused, heavily.
that wouldnt be so bad then, but just thinking about games like league of legends in wich most of the time the most toxic and worst player gets all the votes from their friends while supports and tanks get nothing but abuse
But honestly this is wow, people will find a way to vote trade or to abuse this kind of honor/commendation system
Is there a good system in wow that won’t be abused because it seems to me you always find a way to abuse something so my question is does a system in wow exist that isnt prone to abuse? 🤷🤷🤷.
I can picture trade now. WTS commendation boost, get your mount.
wouldn’t work puny because unless you enter with randoms you would not be able to commendate them at least if Wow copied ff 14’s system you can only give commendations to a friend if they randomly que’ed and happen to be in the same party as you
though it would be heavily in favour of the tank or healer getting all 4 votes
also commendations only happen when the run is finished so you would still have to run a dungeon 500+ times
Yea but at least it gives people something more to do also Puny my friend why are you nude not that I’m complaining but I am curious giggity 
.
/pose seductively
Sounds like a system to deinstivise playing woth friends then
Sure, many systems have weaknesses, but this would be so easy to do. Go with friends or guildies, all nominate the same person. Then you would end up with say a mount that they could trade to someone else in the group. Helping each other farm items via abuse. Multi-boxers could do it even more easily.
this kind of system is like choosing from 2 downsides.
Either it disencourages to play premades with friends but promotes acting better among random people
And if that is not the case then you will see tons of premades upvoting their friends and vote trading
/blushes,oh 
.
As you can tell I’m not a fan of commendation systems and I certainly don’t wish to have something else to farm to get mounts or other rewards.
M plus sellers often have an army of alts so they can even boost your armour type. Unless it excluded people on a bnet level they could cycle through characters to boost ratings. Even if it was a one off to rate you it would be something they could charge for.
It’s like the Cow level topic when people thought they had to farm likes for trust levels. They serve no purpose.
As others have stated it penalises people who play regularly with friends or guildies.
Blizzard stole my Vestments set after I commited trollicide at the Bloodgate to get my transmog.
In game I look like this
