PVP stats, Is it possible that Pros got it wrong?

[Ereckthor-drakthul (Ereckthor)]

I had an idea to put up the stats for PVP into simcraft, counting with reduced critical dmg from 200 to 175 percent in PVP and also included the 40 percent versatility buff.

The bonus DMG of crit in PVP is only 75 percent instead of 100. Therefore the stat value drops by 25 percent.

Versa is easy 40 as we all know.

By this logic I simulated my character and unlike all the guides on the internet tha say haste and critical is the best on for pvp along with the versa, the simulation put absolutly on the top MASTERY, even very close to versatility…

Since I saw this, I wanna know if it is possible that professional PVP warriors actualy got this stat wrong, cause by the simc this stat i so much above crit and haste that it seems like there is almost no benefit in those compare to mastery…

[Gulduckmcdot-ragnaros]

u dunno but i think mastery has a “better” scale than crit and haste, but that doesnt mean its better.

[Deymio-arygos]

i think your sims don‘t include the rage you have to spend on ignore pain. you wanna have as much rage generation as possible to keep IP up while doing dmg. So as venthyr you wanna go crit for big executioner hits and max rage generation due to criting whites. as kyrian you wanna go haste for lower MS cd, maxing out MS dmg and mortal combo procs.