So, Moonsteel Broadsword is required for this quest. Can nab one real easy over on the AH. Cool. However… The quest sword requires one that gives spell power and some of the swords crafted are pre-update so they give stamina and spirit instead. So if you bring a genuine Moonsteel Broadsword to him with the wrong stats then uh… Yeah he don’t accept it.
Blizzard, come on…
I mean REALLY. Come on…
Get your act together.