I’ve done an audit on our roster and it look like we could have 121 missing characters in total
Guild: Immortal
Realm: Runetotem
Had several not so active members of my own kicked. Also lots of other people seem to be missing. The guild only have a handful of members in list when I checked, but yesterday there were about 90.
Pressing “J” on a missing (kicked) charcter only brings up Guild Finder.
Guild: Dark Souls
Realm: Kilrogg
As with everyone else, we have lost multiple accounts it seems. I have 2 accounts and some of my alts on my second account have been removed from the guild; haven’t checked my main account yet. I assume this means same is true for other guild members.
The majority of people still showing on the guild roster seem to be Kilrogg members only although I can see one offline chap from Runetotem still showing in guild.
… Posted from my Classic char because I’m no longer offered Taczin the Kilrogg rogue on my character list
1 Like
I don’t think it is only happening to Kilrogg members - in my guild it is happening to all 3 of our realms
Just to add that I have re-invited one of my alts and he retained his guild rep on rejoining so good to know that wasn’t wiped out, was a little worried about that.
@Meena, I was going to check my chars on other realms after this but yes agree it’d be happening across all 3 most likely
1 Like
Guild: Tolerance
Realm: Nagrand
My character Areana Nagrand was the Gm and upon logging in she is no longer in the guild although my other chars who are officers are. We are missing more than 80% of the guild roster. The roster list shows some guild members but most are just blank slots were the names should be and the guild bank is empty.
The Nagrand server in the realm list shows you have 0 characters on it until you actually click on the server then they are there.
I can also say it is compleatly random who got removed or not, one officer in my guild, got removed on chars he used, where others he not touched for ages where fine.
Guild: The Kingslayers
Realm: Kilrogg
Ontop of having about 150 members removed, my Wife also had one of her characters completed erased
Aralia - Kilrogg
Seems to have been erased as there is an aralia - arathor which still exists.
Guild: We Are The Horde
Server: Runetotem
All characters removed except one of mine, who was made the GM automatically.
Should have been 19 members I think. I have tried using the Guild Finder to get my other characters back in the guild, but my GM character is not seeing any of the pending requests.
Guild bank empty, and should not be.
Guild: Ajda
Server: Nagrand
All characters except my 9 characters removed. One of my chars made GM automatically. Should be 94 members I think. The guild list says 11 characters in guild, but in the roster two of them are blank lines.
Guild bank empty, and should not be.
Pretty much the same as many others have posted here.
477 entries in our log, of removed characters. Way too much to type out here, but we can provide a detailed log if needed for CS.
Guild: Out of Order (which ironically we are now)
Server: Runetotem.
We have re-invited the ones that knocked on the door, and there are a bunch of characters that we expect to re-appear, once they log in over the upcoming days.
However we do hope that this can be resolved by Blizzard, as re-adding everybody manually could become a daunting task. Would prefer spending game time on something else 
1 Like
Hi another guild to add to the list 
Guild: Contra Mundum
Server: Kilrogg
Same as everybody else:
GM’s removed and I’ve been promoted (was snr officer).
Guild bank is empty of items but gold is still there.
Lost a lot of members also - (slowly bring some of these back in)
Surely they have a reset button? Aka back ups of the data before they messed around with it? I honestly think it would be better for them to revert all the changes and start again.
The Chosen Few - Kilrogg joins the club. I was removed as GM, guild bank empty, roster almost fully gone, lot of blank rows in roster. Guild achievements are gone.
Interestingly enough my DH Sheetulva was not removed from guild, even I had not logged on her god knows when.
The heck with everything else, but I’m most sad due losing many offliners who had not logged on even for years, but hibernating peacefully under my guardianship. Now they’re permanently gone, and this feel of loss is very deep.
RIP my beloved old, long gone members
3 Likes
I am not sure this is relevant or not, but I decided to look up guilds on armory that has posted in this thread and there is something wierd going on.
most guilds are listed as double there.
3 Aspiration guilds 2 on kilrogg alliance 1 on Arathor horde (could be an issue)
3 Immortals guild 2 on kilrogg 1 on hellfire
4 Meltdown guilds 2 on kilrogg and 2 on runetotem
2 Swift blades, both on kilrogg.
Osiris doesnt exist at all
2 Forgotten both on kilrogg
Glorfindaal only a mage exists on kilrogg
2 Dark souls both on kilrogg
2 Tolerance both on nagrand
2 the Kingslayers both on kilrogg
we are the horde only 1 on nagrand
2 Ajda nagrand
2 out of order runetotem
3 Contra mundum kilrogg
2 the chosen few on kilrogg
2 vanguard, one on nagrand other one on hellfire (this could be an issue) both alliance.
2 horde united both nagrand
2 Friendship before Glory both on nagrand
2 Tolerance both on nagrand
2 THoF both on nagrand
is smugling peanuts, can not be found at all on armory
2 Dream team, both on kilrogg
2 HRTH both on nagrand
2 Knights of Viminacivm both on kilrogg
no idea if this meens something, but it looks realy wierd that armory shows guilds as double.
edit, some guilds seems to have guilds whit same name on hellifre or Arathor, this could be a reason why things are wierd now.
1 Like
Good spot!
Server: Nagrand
Guild: Horde United
Missing serveral characters in the guild, have several “blank” members.
You might be onto something with this
1 Like
I have no idea, put I just keep editing my post about it, when new people post their guild here.
2 Likes
Its 100% what you think it is, essentially its the time travel paradox but with realms instead of different time lines.
Or as Highlander would say “There can only be one!” so when they have merged the realms any duplicates seem to have juat had 1 of them removed, the problem is this is an issue entirely of blizzards creation for merging realms after about 10 years and now they really have to step up their game to fix it…
In game tickets are currently up to over 5days for a response time.
1 Like