[Reflection] Med'an | The Introduction of the Lost Son of the Last Guardian

Med’an would be an awesome character to introduce to usher in this new era of a potentially Kirin Tor-less Azeroth and the lack of a proper Guardian …


Overview

As both a draenei main and a [Warcraft] comic fan, it is quite possible I’m biased.

Med’an. Med’an is the non-Guardian. He was, then he wasn’t.

Yet, a character with arguably phenomenal potential for this game.

However, I would make the case that the character of Med’an has been mostly mistreated by the player base. Many of the talking points by the most critical voices of the character—and in my experience talking with some of these individuals as well—are based on what they’ve heard through second hand accounts. Seldom have they brought or raised any actual facts surrounding the character, or presented arguments based on the comics and their content.

Following Khadgar’s accident, I would like to suggest that there are a number of reasons as for why Med’an’s introduction could make sense. We lack a strong neutral character that is not bound or restricted by other characters or the factions, allowing it and us to experience stories that are inclined to us as player characters; stories that are more based around our Race, more based around our Class. Additionally, his introduction would be more based in the kind of character archetype Med’an could fit rather than his past exploits.

And an archetype that could serve as a compelling addition, while not overshadowing us.


Background

For those that are not versed in the comic series or Med’an’s story, he is the son of Medivh and Garona Halforcen; and thus of half-orc, half-human, quarter-draenei heritage. He was conceived during Garona’s time in Karazhan, and born shortly following the Fall of Stormwind. Fearing she’d be able to be used against Med’an as well after Llane’s assassination, she left him in the care of the Council of Tirisfal and Meryl Felstorm.

The two volumes of the comic series that feature Med’an are primarily divided between the circumstances of Med’an’s upbringing and training, as well as the founding of the New Council of Tirisfal and his ascension as Guardian due to the old and original council being defunct, as well as the need for the appointment of a new Guardian.


Additional details

[As of 2016, last we heard and know from official sources is that Med’an as a character and the stories in the comics were canon but that his ascension and appointment as Guardian wasn’t. Which sadly was and always felt as a moot point anyway since as early as 2014 we were told that Med’an returned the powers of the Guardian to the council.]


The perhaps most known and also criticized aspects of Med’an regards his affinities.

Similar to his father, Med’an is a multi-class character. While he is primarily seen as a Mage, he has been trained and shown an affinity as a Shaman. Prior to his death Maraad taught him in the ways of the Light and of the Paladin.


Additional details

[If the six cosmic forces as put in place by the First Ones are to be believed, that means that Med’an wields the ‘good’ side of all three categories:

- Order | Disorder
- Life | Death*
- Light | Void

*As the Spirit of Life as used by Shaman is claimed to be related to the cosmic force of Life in some yet unknown way, I loosely count it as Med’an having influence over it as well.]

https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/Magic#The_cosmic_forces

https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/Spirit_(lore)


Without going into too many spoilers [I’ll have the sources and links below this post regardless], the entire point of Med’an’s character and indeed the comic series is to set him up as a worthy successor to his father’s legacy and the title of Guardian. Despite the rounds and arguments often used by those that have quite clearly never read the comics or their actual intrigues themselves of the concern that Med’an is way too powerful, the primary plot of his journey is that he isn’t powerful enough. Thus why he requires the council, why he requires and restores Atiesh.

In fact, it is the sacrifice of Aegwynn adding her powers to his and the rest of the Council of Tirisfal that finally makes Med’an powerful enough to foil the primary antagonist of the two volumes and his story: Cho’Gall.

So much for the infinitely overpowered son of the Last Guardian, hmm?

The comic series concludes with Cho’Gall’s defeat, while the Twilight’s Hammer are described to have been scattered. And so the council decides to go their separate ways, with some deciding to go after the remaining cultists.

https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/Med%27an

https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/New_Council_of_Tirisfal

https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/World_of_Warcraft:_Book_Three

https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/World_of_Warcraft:_Book_Four


Introduction

As I reckon many realise looking at these stories or the sources above, there are a lot of moving parts that I would suggest could have significant pay-offs that come naturally seen to where the story is currently in World of Warcraft.

The most important figures in Med’an’s life happen to be vital characters to the present story, or at least individuals that we have seen take on a similarly leading role around us.

With the Kirin Tor in ruins, Jaina and Meryl both are appointed as central figures in the wake of Dalaran’s destruction for a new mobile and decentralized faction to replace what they had before. While anything as formal as a new and official Council of Tirisfal is likely off the table, something thereto is likely possible and could pave the way for this character.

Beyond this, the Twilight’s Hammer—or rather the Twilight’s Blade as of Midnight—are as much a threat as ever and were the main antagonists of Med’an’s story. With the New Council of Tirisfal having been specifically formed to hunt them down, it feels they too could be as relevant as ever along with either old or new characters found in it.

A character like Valeera is being given new spotlight and as one of the last remaining enforcers of the old council, she’s also likely one of few friends that Med’an has left.

Additional cool details is that Med’an was a canonical wielder of Atiesh, a staff that he reforges and restores in one of the comics no less. Notoriously, the staff was broken in half and its fate unknown as of the Destruction of Dalaran.

If the stars haven’t aligned for Med’an’s official introduction, I don’t know what.


“When the child of the three realms becomes as light, the ancient power will be released. The earth will tremble. The seas will rise up in answer, and all will be madness. A new day will dawn, bringing with it chaos or peace …”

Cho’Gall


So, what purpose would Med’an’s character serve?

Why or what would his introduction yield for the story, for the gameplay?

In my opinion, we lack a central neutral character that can guide the player through non-faction or cross-faction storylines similar to how Khadgar did for us in past expansions. A character that could have his own compelling story to tell, breathe some fresh air into the world by being a new face, while still being anchored to characters we know.

His multi-racial and multi-class aspects too become a strength, as they instead emphasize how he can be related to by most Races and Classes as a figurehead. He draws upon all known cosmic forces [as presented briefly above], which all classes in essence in turn are based upon in one way or another.

As for his actual character, I am of the mind that Med’an should be tied to the archetype of the Reluctant Chosen One, the Innocent Hero. An Aang [The Last Airbender] or an Ezra Bridger [Star Wars Rebels]—a character that shoulders an immense burden and power, with shoes that are more or less impossible to fill. But he has faith, a moral compass.

While many will cry for the need of a Guardian in present day following his return, Med’an should be the foremost voice speaking up for us—the Heroes of Azeroth. That the powers of a Guardian won’t be necessary so long as we’re here.

… Albeit requiring to be nudged in the right direction every now and then.


Thanks for reading!

I understand where you’re coming from, but there are reasons why they shelved that character. Med’an was just too much, basically the embodiment of an OP self-insert stereotype that even overshadowed Varian in terms of “snowflakeyness”.

Introduced in a comic, the son of two prominent lore characters (who of course, never mentioned him in any way, shape or form), a Draenei-Human-Orc mix who then challenged Cho’Gall in a Dragonball-style energy-blast battle… that didn’t feel like WoW anymore, but a fan-fiction, a character concept of a new player on a RP-realm, that made people facepalm whenever they read it.

He was too special to really fit into the story - the complexity of his character concept would have required a delicate and step-by-step introduction over time (like f.e. Calia as a Light-Undead), a medium that helped dive into his personality, like a novel. Instead, they just created a OP hybrid-race-hybrid-class-NPC for a comic and threw the title “Guardian of Tirisfal” on him. No depth, no real nuance.

In comparison, I really liked Khadgar’s approach; storywise, as a Warcraft veteran character, he was best fit to be Medivh’s successor, but in the end, he didn’t give in to the promise of power. The “power” Khadgar wielded was the ability to lead and guide us againts the enemy, us, as the “true power” of Azeroth. And that’s special, because unlike Jaina (or Med’an), we never saw him blast his enemies to bits - his use of magic was mostly tactical and efficient, never overwhelming - that’s what Khadgar added to the story. He is a powerful human mage, but still has to run away, improvise or even take a rest sometimes. That makes us feel like he is “one of us” to a certain degree. Med’an would give too much “special snowflake vibes” to even establish a connection like that.

But we already had exactly that with Anduin and his whole coming of age story. The boy who didn’t want to be King, who didn’t want to fight, but had to grow into it, until he was put into a scenario that took his innocence from him and made him a man.

In my opinion, it’s kind of exhausting if they focus on the same characters for too long, especially with the huge ensemble that we have now in Alliance and Horde leadership - I was happy when they ended Varian, just as I had enough of Sylvanas’ story at the end of SL. Adding another “special snowflake” character to that mix would only complicate things, especially with Med’ans story background.

So, respectfully, I have to disagree with you. We need NPCs that we can connect with, who are like us, at least to a certain degree. Med’an would just be another one-man-show and we’ve had enough of those.

And where are these suggestions and ideas of him being overpowered coming from?

I completely understand the concerns regarding similarities to other characters, not in the least someone like Anduin. Another character that would be close contender to my presented idea is Wrathion. The difference being that Wrathion started down this path of being our disconnected non-faction guide through various intrigues in Mists of Pandaria until he suddenly began coveting for us to follow his own arguably selfish agenda in lieu of, quote, “world peace”.

Personally, I’d suggest these two arcs are far enough apart from Med’an however.

He would be shouldering the expectations of the powers of the Guardian and the legacy of his father, regardless of whether he wants that or not. In comparison to Anduin here, there was never even a suggestion to the alternative since Anduin never had the choice being the son of a monarch and being next in line to the throne. We as players would be asking what gives in terms of Med’an, and could have expectations about his power level depending on how much one knows about him. You could even write this cheekily as [similar to how you’re arguably doing] the assumption from many players that know his name is that Med’an is overpowered. Thus, he could put those questions to rest easily.


Now for this part …

He has never done this either, so I am once again bewildered as for where this argument is coming from. As I mention in my post, this has been a common thread from people objecting to his character with absolutely no sources what so ever to back this claim up. The greatest enemy of his stories is Cho’Gall, who we’ve foiled … thrice now?

Do you actually know or are you simply repeating what you’ve heard over the years?

In fact, if we are to delve into his character … Med’an is an extremely humble individual.

During the battle, Med’an intuitively wove together arcane and shamanic magic to defeat the ancient creature, then healed Valeera by simultaneously calling upon the power of the Light and the earth. Unaware that he had done anything special, he remarked simply that he had only done what others had taught him, and that he still had much to learn.

https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/Med%27an#New_Council_of_Tirisfal

Meryl, who had recently returned from a meeting in Ahn’Qiraj with Garona, during which he tasked her with finding the [Base of Atiesh], was forced to rely again upon the power of the demon Kathra’natir, and a hasty attempt to infuse Med’an with the powers of the council failed and knocked him unconscious, but Broll Bearmantle’s arrival paved the way for a victory.

Upon awakening, Med’an was informed by Aegwynn that the council, now complete, was preparing a formal investiture ceremony. He explained to her that he had traveled to Karazhan and there had been granted knowledge and power by his father.

https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/Med%27an#Guardian_of_Tirisfal

Restoring Atiesh, Greatstaff of the Guardian to its rightful state, Med’an focused the powers of the council through it to defeat Cho’gall. Following the battle, the Council mourned the death of Aegwynn, but Med’an offered them comfort, saying that she willingly gave her life and will live on through him. With the battle over, Med’an returned the powers to the Council,[5] thanking them for letting him see the world through their eyes and showing him how much he has yet to learn.

https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/Med%27an#Return_to_Ahn'Qiraj

This is what the biggest battles in Med’an’s stories boil down to.

And as such, I ask you, … where are these examples of him being overpowered?

While his story unquestionably includes some wild ideas—which are more than fine to have opinions on—I do take issue with the repeated, as I consider them, unsubstantiated claims that he is “OP” when his entire character arc sees Med’an struggling with never being powerful enough to fill the shoes of the legacy he unfairly carries. And constantly requiring the council’s aid, no less. Despite this, he continues to carry himself with a humble disposition.

My love for Med’an stems from what we see of his heart.

An individual born from a mother and father touched by incomprehensible evil, raised by an ancient Forsaken mage as his caretaker, expressing such great amounts of love and care for the people around him.

I remain convinced that this is a character we could use as a non-faction character that bridges our understanding in times of strife to focus on why we’re fighting and what we’re fighting for, that is able to connect to almost all of the cosmic forces and thus the classes and a whole lot of the existing races as well.

And thus mantle a similar role to the one I’d posit Wrathion was initially being set up for.

There is no need for that, they already established that with Khadgar as Medivh’s far more legitimate “heir”. We even saw Medivh talk to Khadgar in the revamped Karazhan - to just re-insert Med’an and act like it’s totally normal for him to suddenly be there would just be weird as hell.

You’ve quoted it yourself:

Intuitively, he combined two forms of magic on several occasions and didn’t even notice he did something special, because it was just so easy for him to do.
He might not be a classical Gary Stu, but everything about Med’an’s character just SCREAMS “Look, I’m special!” A hybrid of three races, son of prominent characters, given a unique title with amazing abilities and of course, a “soft-retcon”-character, because one day, somebody thought: “Hey, what if… Medivh and Garona had a secret son who’s been there all along?!”

It’s mostly about his potencial. Some would say being a Magepriestshaman class-hybrid would already be OP, but we’re talking about a barely adult magepriestshaman who is already empowered to be Guardian of Tirisfal - being OP comes with the job.
That’s why it rubbed people the wrong way, because the character basically came out of nowhere and was elevated by established NPCs into this special role; hence the “fanfiction” criticism. He wasn’t woven into the overall story, he was spawned.

We’ve seen the “reluctant chosen one who struggles with his father’s legacy” story now twice, with Anduin and with Wrathion. Reintroducing Med’an and giving him a similar story would just be repetitive and boring - it would also undermine Khadgar’s character journey. Of course, that’s just my opinion. :man_shrugging:

2 Likes

Indubitably!

Personally, I feel you’re grasping at straws in terms of the lack of any examples of being directly overpowered. Additionally, Medivh is an expressed multi-class hero. This isn’t a new concept. What is new is Med’an being able to combine those energies, which I am absolutely fascinated by and would love to see more of or again.

The point about the similarities to Anduin [or Wrathion as I added] is absolutely valid, as far as I’m concerned. But I have faith they’d be able to pull it off. Not in the least since it could be a point in the story itself.

The biblical reference of the Sins of the Father, with Med’an making up the full set to have us fulfil the narrative Rule of Three and point to those parallels is arguably a perfectly viable approach.

I’m not grasping at straws, I told you, it’s about potencial. Characters who are just special and powerful for the sake of being special and powerful disrupt the story in my opinion.
Varian Wrynn is another example for that. Even though he existed before Cataclysm, his re-introduction was just as messy as Med’an’s origins. Once again, done in a comic with a very… “unique” story about a Stormwind human split in two who was turned into the chosen avatar of a Kalimdor ancient he didn’t even know. Later, during the first battle against Xavius in the Emerald Dream (in the novel), he was chosen by Elune to lead Azeroths armies, because… well, he was special. When they showed actual character development for him in the BfA cinematic, I knew they would kill him off soon (of course, once again in the most dramatic and overblown way while making another character look incompetent) - because he was written as a stereotype, not as an actual character with nuance.

Imho, Med’an falls under the same category - a snowflake character, written to be special. So special that they outshine everyone around them. Of course, Blizzard could introduce him into the game and give him the Wrathion treatment (aka turning the plot-armored snowflake into a nuanced character with actual character traits), but… as I said, I just don’t see what Med’an would add that isn’t already there / has already been shown.

I would rather see more stories that focus on the established characters and give them more depth - especially on the Horde council, after all the losses and personal changes they had.

Yet … I’d suggest Med’an was already special simply because of his heritage. If he only was the son of Medivh and nothing else, he’d arguably still have a this shadow looming over him.

Regardless of what they did with him, he’d unquestionably be a unique character.

And personally, simply to have this mentioned, if one was to step into the room and say “So they shouldn’t have made him” is one of those things I feel can be applied to everything.

Because then we might as well just stop making anything for anyone.

And so to me the question always becomes—what do we do with what we have?

I don’t have the power cross out things I don’t like from this franchise, so I far more enjoy rearranging the moving pieces of the board to see what could make them fit a bit better.

Not to mention it makes it a bit more positive, you know?

As far as we know, Med’an still exists. The last note we have is that him becoming Guardian isn’t canon [as mentioned above], but that his adventures most definitely are. That might change, it might not. And so if they were to introduce him, I reckon this’d be the best way.

This way we connect to what he was, to a purpose of what he could be.

I’d rather say “They shouldn’t have introduced him like that”. As I mentioned, it’s the stack of “snowflakyness” that made people dislike him. In my opinion, they picked the wrong medium to introduce such a special a complex character (concept). Compared to novels or the possibilites ingame, comics are superficial and bound to be short and “on-the-nose” in terms of subtext and storytelling.

The biggest factor in my opinion is the cross-media-transition - such a story needs to be told ingame; otherwise people would just be confused. After all, the whole Guardian-story and the involvement of Cho’gall is not exactly a B-plot, it’s pretty big in terms of the overall story.

If they ever put him into the game, they would need to do some story groundwork first; above everything, the question where he has been all this time and rework how the whole “guardian”-thing fits in canoncially.

If they just took the the comic character 1:1, I would have no choice but to agree with this gentleman :sweat_smile:

https://i.gyazo.com/92421020dee85a1b328245859a99b689.png

They should if it ever comes to it, highly unlikely they will. Because I absolutely agree.

Yet this has almost never been done before, as regrettable as it may be.

We can use the Wolfheart novel as an example [spoilers, just as a warning!] …


When a murdered Highborne is discovered on the outskirts of Darnassus, Malfurion and Tyrande move to stop further bloodshed and unrest by appointing one of the night elves’ most cunning and skilled agents to find the killer: the renowned warden Maiev Shadowsong. Yet with all that is transpiring in Darnassus, the Alliance might be powerless to stop the relentless new warchief Garrosh from seizing the whole of Ashenvale.[3]

https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/Wolfheart

When the Highborne mage Thera’brin was assassinated and his corpse was found near the Watchers’ training grounds, it seemed to be intended to impute the Watchers. Maiev offered her services to investigate the matter and bring the murderer to justice, to which Malfurion and Tyrande consented. In truth, however, she was secretly the one responsible for the Highborne killings. Maiev had planned to slaughter the Highborne and their leaders first, and then give Malfurion a slow rotting death.

https://warcraft.wiki.gg/wiki/Maiev_Shadowsong#Wolfheart


This is subsequently never addressed or brought up again, and somehow Maiev is still a Warden and leader of the Watchers at that come Legion as though nothing happened.

An arguably absolutely phenomenal novel, but this discrepancy between the game and other material found from other sources is sadly par for the course.

We’ll have to make do with what we get, I reckon. Or so I see it, anyway.

Yes, I found that weird as well. Even though at the time, I was cheering on Maiev for defending the little “race profile” the Night Elves still had at the time, it’s strange to never see it addressed in the story again. I guess that happens when there are too many cooks in the kitchen; just like the Garrosh story, where his behaviour didn’t fit his personality in Stonetalon.