All 3 talents are not amazing, when I check e.g. What Earthliving Does, it’s like 1% of my healing when I pick it.
It feels like a mandatory talent choice ( any of the 3) and they’re all crap for a Talent at that level. Can we either get a decent talent or a Direct link from Flow of the Tides to Earthen Harmony ?
Earthliving becomes more meaningful when playing totemic because you get a guaranteed proc on every group member when casting chain heal after placing surging totem. (including the free chain heal through placing HST/CB totem) But all in all it’s a bit boring yes. Earthen Wall Totem is only useful in PvP so the choice here is, unfortunately, pretty clear. Maybe when playing farseer you could argument using it over earthliving and do things like double earthen wall with totemic recall…