It’s a nice post, I agree and disagree on different things but I think both have their strengths and weaknesses in certain areas.
I find the loot systen similar, in classic you fight RNG + Loot competitors, in retail you fight the greater RNG element, both feel very similar to me.
Tokens? Completely agree. Farming gold is gone, you just buy it, the richer you are IRL the richer you are in wow and no level of farming or gameplay will change that thabks to tokens. Also all farming is now inefficient if time is the #1 value involved.
I love transmog, it’s nice that player power will be distinguished by their name rather than the colour of their armour to me, having the kind of customization over your character is key to a good RPG I think, games that call themselves RPG but lack in customization is always a critique from me.
It is a broken system, classic is not entirely better tho. No matchmaking is one of the key factors, freshly dinged 120s go against fully fledged mythic raiders, it is a stupid system, this kind of balance is stuff for world pvp, you can essentially call a win or loss without watching people play, gear is just that important.
Since CRZ has been released I find this to be the reverse of my experience, I can quest in areas and see many other players, before CRZ they would be nearly barren, honestly for all the stick it gets it does what it was ment to do, there is just little reason for interaction - other players presence will often just serve to hinder you, particularly in lower areas where wpvp is not a thing.
It gets stick from many players but I disagree, LFR is a great tool plagued by elitist players who resent casuals for being casual, for many players this is as far as their raiding experiences will take them and I don’t resent that at all, raiding is fun and the more who get to participate the better chance such content has.
At this stage I think they are both games with their own strengths and weaknesses, both have ups and downs, neither is better or worse than the other as they both seek to offer something different. They are both different games with the only real similarities being some graphics, areas, abilties, characters and basic quests.
For you. This will apply to some and not to others, for the cost of one subscription you can play both and players will make their own choices.
Classic is okay for me but I’m on hold until all the content is released, I don’t really wanna wait and be drip fed old content, especially when the current meta involes what it does.