So for context.
I started playing SoD with the intent of maining Rogue tanking, as it sounded fun and appealing to me personally. (I enjoy tanking)
For phase 1:
It was fun to tank dungeons (started about lvl 20, due to requirement to get the rune)
Tanked my way till 25, thru questing, leveling and got to 25. Started to tank BFD while 2 tanks were a thing, and later turned to dps as a rogue tank had no reliable way of Solo tanking BFD without mobs being aggroed to everyone. Which is fair, rogues doesn’t typically have AoE abilities in classic (Except Blade Flurry)
Now, one thing I noticed. Even while only being a Single target tank, was that my threat felt lackluster compared to dps? If a warlock was doing 90 dps, and I was doing 70. I would have to battle hard to keep aggro, whereas with other tanks in classic. I felt a lot more smooth.
Phase 2:
Shuriken toss came around! my lord and saviour. I thought. turns out, due to Muti buff, it isn’t that great. And in most cases you are better of muti spamming and tab targeting, which is what I did not particularily enjoy in P1 either.
So my question is, or plea if you may.
Could we had a increased threat component to Shuriken toss, in the same way Molten Blast have for Shaman? As this will lessen the stress when doing aoe tanking as a rogue, and would not hamper or mess with other aspect of the game (PvP or even AoE as a dps rogue, as you lack the chest rune to double dip the threat then (Presumably))
Additionally, I am a bit confused about the massive threath increase. As it seems to be 50% like with warlock tanks, but it just does not feel like it’s active all the time or that it is accurate. As I’ve had cases where I would on a boss do 200 dps, and a warlock doing 250, but he would still overaggro me? But Maybe they have some spells that does Increased threat and that is why.
But what are other rogue tanks experience? Are you having some problems? Is there some QoL you seek as a rogue tank?
And for Blizzard, outside of my small grieviances that lead to some aggro issues that is a personal headache for me, I’m really enjoying it. It’s simple, but that’s classic. So Thank you for this experience, I’m having fun <3