this argument simply doesnt make sense.
a Rework isnt a Pruning, and i think the concept on you is lost… the idea of Pruning is Actively removing things from a Specc, the Specc undertook a Rework not a prune… it simply didnt take a rework in Favor of what u want from the specc.
its really easy to sympathize with those who are Losing their Favorite playstyles… and Want blizzard to actually do this correctly.
but you make it ALOT harder.
all your progression is Made with healing… yet you insist on making Serious arguments on Shadow… Which is a Specc you dont seem to play in any competitive manner in the slightest Outside the likely solo content u use a DPS Specc for.
the problems are quite Obvious with this Talent… yet you are Trying to actively push this idea of “WE ALL WANT THIS TO STAY” yet it remains Obvious this is a Mixed Reviewed topic of People on both sides…
the concept is to find the compromise that doesnt leave either side of the argument completely burnt. and i dont think making a Fourth Specc would be hard either… all they need to do is
Take BFA Shadow… Change the name to void priest… take the New Design of Shadow Call it Shadow Priest and change the new designed Shadow to a Shadow Theme.
Players against Void form… get Orginal Shadow Identity back
Players For Void form. get to keep their Void identity.
Instead of Flaming every player who want the New Design and Trying to push a Narrative… why not spend ur time actually giving your critism towards their attempt to replicate it for you guys. cause that quite Urgently does Need some Feedback pushed against. maybe also play the specc abit :P.
the concept as a whole is Weak.
The concept of these types of talents have never had a happy ending, gladiator stance and more… all went to dumpster realistically.
The concept of a Talent Prevents it from ever being progressed… it also means every design choice from SL Onwards will Actively counteract the Purpose of said talent.
Take current DP for example… its Actively immediately unusable the moment you Use that talent… because it Actively goes against the purpose of the Playstyle given with said talent.
It’ll never be balancable… and it seems more like a Act of “slowly ripping the band aid off” as they’ll progress this new iteration of Shadow… and Simply proclaim "LoTV cant uphold its pujrpose anymore so we’ll remove it in favor for this new talent " Just like they did with every talent like this.
it needs to become a Full blown fourth specc if it has any hope of actually being useful, they cant introduce major changes to try make the talent work without Causing potiental balancing issues upholding 2 playstyles in 1 Specc
imho, if they do actualy wanna Do things Right for the playerbase wanting this playstyle… they need to make it a Fourth Specc and call it void priest… then just change the New Design of Shadow priest to a Shadow Aesthetic.