Maybe for you and some others. But think about it… There is a reason why I never play Horde for Story/PvE or RP.
Instead of allowing the players to identify themself by own choice with both factions, Blizzard kind-off forces the players to identify with factions based on their character creation preferences.
I would never play an Undead. I would never play a Tauren. I would never play an Orc. I would never play Troll (neither Zandalari nor regular). I only have a Bloodelf Paladin on Horde side to unlock allied races… And Vulpera and Nightborn were the only interesting ones. Now, if I want to play a Nightborn I have to either play a class I don’t (really) like or not at all.
A game should not put me in a situation like this for most races.
Let me make an example…
Every Race on Horde can be:
- Warrior
- Hunter
- Death Knight
Almost every Race can be:
- Mage (exception Taurens) (10/12)
- Rogue (exception Taurens) (10/12)
- Priest (exception Highmountain Tauren and default Orcs) (10/12)
- Warlock (exception Pandaren, Taurens, Mag’har, Zandalari) (7/12)
- Shaman (exception Forsaken, Bloodelfs, Nightborn) (9/12)
- Monk (exception Goblins) (11/12)
A few Races can be:
- Paladin (Bloodelf, regular Tauren, Zandalari) (3/12)
- Druid (Tauren and Trolls only) (4/12)
Only one Race can be:
- Demon Hunter (Bloodelf) (1/12)
Now my preferences of classes…
The classes I like to play:
The Classes I am ok with:
- Death Knight
- Warrior
- Mage
The classes I rather don’t like to play:
- Rogue
- Hunter
- Priest
- Demon Hunter (not available for Nightborn ofc)
Classes I never played / don’t like by default:
Classes I played once or have no specific opinion about:
In conclusion means…
The classes I would play as a Nightborn:
- Warrior
- Mage
- Death Knight
Since this Character is meant to be played both PvE and RP on Argent Dawn, this means the only Solution is Mage. I already have like 2-3 Warriors. I can’t play Paladin on Nightbore. And a Death Knight goes against of the requirements I want for the Character to fit in in the Roleplay-Aspect of the Character I have in mind.
This means, that out of 12 classes I can play 8 with the Nightborn, limited to 3 of my personal likings and to only 1 final result of class choice.
And while one can say that is totally fine to create such a “narrowing down” with the thought process when creating the character, the personal limitations and the restrictions of the classes result in a kind-off “forced” player experience.
In conclusion this means that Horde is in general more unattractive to me as a player because of…
- Only 3 Races that suit my preferences in Appearance (female Bloodelf, Vulpera, Nightborn)
- 2 of those 3 Races have fitting classes (Bloodelf, Vulpera)
- Only 1 Race can chose Paladin as Class, considering the preferences in Appearance and Limitations
TLDR: Alliance offers more choice for classes I like than Horde does, resulting in ME being kind-off forced to play Alliance and making the Character experience on Horde for me almost unbearable.