I’m not here to just complain about the state of the spec, but I want to try to reason with blizzard why havoc is hot trash right now.
I’ve been playing DH since legion and I’ve been on top guilds across EU and US servers(US during legion). I have top logs and I’m still currently playing Havoc for my guild as we thought we would need the 5% buff from DH. We are a guild on Kazzak that usually ranks around top 110-140 world so my experience is obviously from a cutting edge point of view.
Currently, Havoc is the worse melee on single target alongside arms/fury and maybe assasination rogue, but nobody plays that spec right now. On AOE I think havoc is fine, it’s still under a lot of other specs, but I’m okay being middle of the pack. I’m even okay with a spec being bottom of the pack as long as it’s needed for a buff or utility in raids.
The biggest issue besides being at the bottom of the pack in DPS is the fact that Vengeance is so strong that most top guilds won’t bring in a Havoc for their 5% buff, and would utilize Vengeance for the buff. This leaves Havoc completely in the dust.
Our guild is currently on Mythic Council and will be killing it this week and we will move forward to sludgfist. On sludgfist, you are limited to 4 melees only and those melees on any guild that wants to seriously attempt to kill it right now would be
1- Unholy DK
2- Sub Rogue
3- Wind Walker Monk
(these specs all outperform havoc by an insanely large margin)
https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/7tKe3X6UeckmBCu8t979Zq
(our WW who just switched from BM sims around 6.2k single target)
https://www.raidbots.com/simbot/report/7KLkNeoAJGBErHuQH58Le4
(Me as havoc with 222ilvl sim around 5.3k)
That’s 1k under a WW on a ST fight around 20-25% better than Havoc. Same goes for unholy and Sub rogue btw.
4- Holy Paladin as a healer is a must unfortunately.
If you bring another melee to that fight you are just trolling yourself. Not that it matters at this point, but 90% of guilds copy what limit and echo would do on a fight that’s so tight as a DPS check.
Again, I have no issue with being at the bottom of the pack in DPS as long as I can play my spec in the raid. With the current state of Vengeance being SO strong, Havoc either needs a massive buff on single target or Vengeance needs a massive nerf. Nobody in their right mind would ever play or bring Havoc again if it continues to be this bad on ST. In my opinion Havoc needs a complete rework, but I know that’s not happening, so either buff us or just remove havoc from the game completely.
If you want to kill a spec this bad just say so officially so we all stop playing this garbage spec.