Neither are you. But let’s not go to personal attacks. We’re both adults after all.
Forsaken humans aren’t much better, but let’s for a second realize how long night elves live. They live far longer than human mind can comprehend, serving their people faithfully for potentially thousands of years. Are you honestly going to tell me that all it takes is ‘‘betrayal’’ to make them turn on their entire race? So your people just experienced near genocide. What do you do? Help your former enemy finish the job of course. How on earth is that plausible? I can get wanting to get back on Maiev/Tyrande, but going this far?
…They are totally different. Their race, lifespans, motivations, cultures, geopolitical decisions and positionings, their surroundings upon being reanimated, their killers, are all different. Not really sure why you’d even ask such a question.
Considering that there are Night Elves running around in the Twilight Hammer with far less motivation (and enhanced negative emotions from dying/undeath) yeah.
Lest we forget, Fandral Staghelm switched sides to Old Gods/Ragnaros because his kid died and he felt betrayed. He didn’t even die himself.
Why is Fandral’s heel-turn because of personal tragedy okay but Sira’s/Delaryn’s are not?
Actually, I’m intelligent enough to know when I’m not right and I have many a time either admitted defeat in an argument or accepted the fact that the argument is pointless. If I can be proven wrong, then I’ll accept it. But so far none of the replies Elenthas and others have given have convinced me that the writing makes sense.
Because his tragedy was building up for over a thousand years and because he was slowly descending into darkness the natural way. What is the excuse for those two SUDDENLY changing mind?
That is like every forsaken ever. Doesn’t make diffrence really.
Elves: Yes, Blood Elves are slightly same and still they are dark rangers.
Age: So? Doesn’t make any diffrence to being 10k years old vs 30 years
Motivation: They are given one.
Culture: What this has to do with it? They liked their tree in life, now they don’t.
Geopolitical decisions: Red army marches to north, seemingly
Their surroundings: Might get slightly scared but they get used to it.
Their killers: Somebody has to kill them. They might have revenge on them.
Both Sira and Delaryn claim that Elune and Tyrande abandoned them post-resurrection. How that is any different to, i.e, how Arthas brainwashed his death knights?
It is elegantly put under another perspective, so I fail to see how it is trash.
i did. While I agree that your reasoning is sound, I still don’t agree with her going against her entire race instead of specifically against Tyrande/Maiev. And the undeath warping minds is no excuse as she had to be willing to be raised so therefore she made such a decision consciously.
This is a pretty ludicrous statement and I have nothing more to add to this except that it makes literally no sense whatsoever.
Because we were shown that post-ressurection, both Tyrande and Maiev were ready to have them back.
I personally don’t think either make sense, but one could argue that a being who had much more time to form themselves would be harder to sway than a being that is literally a toddler in comparison but that’s just me.
And you could just as easily say that they’ve lived so long they’re far more attached to their life and don’t want to see it end, to be snuffed out, and will jump at the opportunity to continue it.
