Troll tribe ranking

This is biased of course but I will put it out regardless. So lets start.

  1. Amani. The OG troll tribe of the game. It is a shame they aren’t playable yet.
  2. Zandalari. The royalty of the race not as cool as Amani but the golden stuff makes up for it.,
  3. Drakkari. Blizzard did them dirty. I hope they can revive now that the scourge is gone.
  4. Gurubashi. The cool jungle trolls and I hope they aren’t dead yet.
  5. Farraki. Sadly reduced to boring villains. Maybe in the future the Sand trolls can start to be relevant again.
  6. Darkspear. a bunch of poop slingers without culture. It was a great mistake to make them playable over the Amani. Blizzard must have been on drugs for doing this. Shame on all Devs. No one wanted them.
1 Like

I wanted them!

*Flings poop at Lorcathar*

5 Likes

I good troll is a dead one

2 Likes

Thanks for proving my point.

(1) Drakkari: I absolutely loved the Zul’Drak zone in WotLK! The entire zone felt like a massive city—one in decay and ruin. I can’t help but imagine what it might have been like if the Drakkari hadn’t been on a path of self-destruction, sacrificing their own Loa to steal their powers. Perhaps they could have rivaled the grandeur of the Zandalari’s city, Zul’Dazar. I agree that Blizzard didn’t do them justice. At the very least, it feels like a missed opportunity. It’s so obvious that a raid tier in Gun’Drak was planned but ultimately scrapped—presumably in favor of Trial of the Crusader (TotC).

Zul’Drak remains a haunting reminder of what might have been—a zone that offered a glimpse into a once-great civilization, undone by its own hubris, and left me yearning for more of the story that was never told.


(2) Zandalari: The role they played in the Mists of Pandaria expansion was incredible. In fact, I’d go as far as to say I enjoyed the Zandalari’s mini-invasion and takeover of the Isle of Thunder far more than the Garrosh storyline and its events. Wouldn’t it have been so much cooler if Mists of Pandaria had focused on a massive Zandalari invasion and conquest, rather than being a soft Horde vs. Alliance conflict that culminated in the Siege of Orgrimmar?

Imagine if the storyline revolved around the Zandalari, whose lands were devastated by the Cataclysm, launching an all-out invasion. Instead of Garrosh seeking the heart of Y’Shaarj, it could have been Zul driving the events forward.

Fast-forwarding to Battle for Azeroth—say what you will about the systems or endgame content, but in terms of lore, story, and thematics, it stands out as one of the best expansions in my view. The Blood Trolls and G’huun, King Rastakhan’s deal with Bwonsamdi, the Vulpera of Vol’dun, and the story of Mythrax all created an incredible narrative.

I do feel for those who played Alliance during that expansion—the Horde-specific questing and lore were just leagues ahead in terms of depth and excitement.


(3) Gurubashi and Farraki: I always think of these tribes as the originals—or at least the first I remember encountering in-game. The Sand Trolls and Jungle Trolls inhabit the southern reaches of each continent: Eastern Kingdoms and Kalimdor, respectively. I think I prefer the Gurubashi tribe slightly more, as they seem to have a stronger presence in the lore and received more attention in the game. That said, I absolutely loved Zul’Farrak—one of my favorite classic dungeons. It would easily make my top 5.

Speaking of nostalgia, a zone that always stands out in people’s minds—both for good and bad reasons—is Stranglethorn Vale. Setting aside the infamous world PvP and relentless ganking, what truly made this zone memorable and dangerous was its rich story and atmosphere. The lore, the jungle vibe, and the constant sense of danger from the Gurubashi trolls all contributed to making Stranglethorn Vale an unforgettable experience.


(4) Amani: I must admit, I know relatively little about the Amani tribe in terms of lore. While these Forest Trolls occupy a significant number of zones in World of Warcraft—stretching from the Arathi Highlands and beyond—they don’t seem to stand out to me as much as the Gurubashi or Farraki.

Despite their presence in multiple zones and expansions, such as Ghostlands and Zul’Aman in The Burning Crusade, the Amani have never quite captured the spotlight in the same way as the other troll tribes. Perhaps this is because their story, rooted in a distant past, was never fully explored or presented in the game. In contrast, the Gurubashi and Farraki have had more moments of active villainy or intrigue within the game’s narrative, making their presence more memorable for me.


(5) Darkspear: I agree with you—it often feels like the Darkspear Tribe is treated as an afterthought. Unlike other troll tribes, they lack grandeur, monumental cities, or significant impacts on zones. There are no grand temples or sprawling ruins tied to their history, making them feel less distinct when compared to tribes like the Zandalari or Amani.

This is partly due to the fact that the Darkspear are a younger tribe with less established lore and development. Their story is intrinsically tied to the Horde, and much of their identity revolves around their role as loyal allies to the faction rather than as a standalone culture. While this makes sense narratively, it also means that their unique heritage and contributions often fade into the background of the larger Horde storyline.

Still, the Darkspear have had their moments of heroism, particularly under the leadership of Vol’jin, whose wisdom and sacrifices left a lasting impact on the Horde. Perhaps with further storytelling and deeper exploration of their roots, the Darkspear could step out of the shadows and develop a more defined identity within the Warcraft universe.


Closing Thoughts
Trolls will always have some of the best lore and storytelling in World of Warcraft, both past, present, and future. Who knows? Perhaps one day we’ll discover that the Blood Trolls of Nazmir were never truly defeated. In secret, they’ve made their way to the shores of Stranglethorn Vale, where they are once again performing dark rituals to rebirth the Blood God Hakkar and unleash the Blood Plague upon the citizens of Azeroth… Zul’Gurub 3.0. :stuck_out_tongue:

2 Likes

1.Dark Troll
While the Amani Tribe / remnants of the Amani Empire joined the Old Horde that “alliance” not lasted that long and the Amani became the enemy of everyone.
The Shadowtooth clan fought side by side with Thrall’s Horde and aided the night elves and the Alliance for the World!
Unlike the Amani or Gurubashi, the dark trolls sought a peaceful connection to the natural world, and their mystics sought ways to commune and live in harmony with the land.
They could have been the perfect playable Troll Race, in tune with the setting Warcraft 3 left to the WoW to built on
The Tauren and the shamanistic orcs would have loved them

2.Zandalari
Troll of the Trolls with an Empire and history
They even able to walk upright

3.The rest
The rest are the rest, nothing to see here, move along.

I appreciate it when people give due respect to the trolls of wow. I enjoyed reading your text really. And I agree that the Darkspear feel like an extra addition not able to stand on their own without the Orcs.

Its sad that Dark Trolls, who were interesting if only because they sided with the Night Elves when the Legion attacked Hyjal, are completely ignored ingame. They had such potential, could have even been an Allied race, instead Blizzard just gets rid of them with a flimsy “Twilight Cult killed them” excuse. Heck they could have even added them in TWW instead of that weird shapeshifting Pandora race. Can’t even remember the name, that’s how uninteresting they are.

I remember how exited I was in Warcraft 3 when the Dark Trolls joined in the last mission. Like things are so bad even Trolls that were normally just random obstacles on some maps join you and fight the Legion. Really gave the vibe of a last stand of Azeroth, everyone vs the Legion.

2 Likes

Darkspear trolls. Didnt like Zandalari for any other than the aztec and mayan theme and I dont know enough of the other trolls. I always liked Darkspear trolls and some of my first characters were trolls, their casting animations are same as Ryu’s hadoken and they look cool. They even had “troll” racials that let them regenerate health slowly.

2 Likes

I would drop my other character If we get forest Trolls.

1 Like

I like the stranglethorn vale jungle trolls, they are founded by darkspear it seems :dracthyr_a1:

  1. Amonet
  2. Every other troll

Amonet is not a troll tribe :dracthyr_a1:

The Zandalorians…

everything is mud on their boots

Ofc I am, are you discriminating me?

No, we have the records of lore in wowpedia and there is no tribes with that name. Anyways I like Jungle troll above any other troll tribes :dracthyr_a1:

amonet is a troll ? :thinking: an elf troll ?

1 Like

An illusion!

1 Like

So yes blood elves are directly rated to night elves, but 3 evolutions apart, even further from trolls. Troll>NightElf>HighBorne>HighElves>BloodElves. But highborne were biologically identical to regular NE, it was after the sundering that they changed into thalassian elves or Nightborne.

1 Like

And the original playable trolls in game are darkspear trolls like your character which I think looks just awesome in general and inspirated me to go find this vendor named Ya’mon :dracthyr_hehe:

1 Like