Sadly it doesn’t happen anymore, I know it deeply. But when I started it partially it was happening.
In PvP as arms you can still stack modifiers out of the wazoo, and as it is not about overall damage to be efficent; but kill windows - yeah, warrior can still do something and not feel too bad.
I am happy and glad you still can get that dream scenario in-game 
(M+ tho, the dream is dead and sunk)
There needs to be a scoring system outside of timing keys.
Did a Dawn 10 tonight where at 36 interrupts I had more than the rest of the group combined.
Hard CCs was the same picture, as was the use of defensives and potions.
and yet I had the lowest Rio by a good margin (I haven’t pushed)
Id like Warriors to be seen as the masters of interrupts/cc. Lower CDs on all our interrupts and stuns and CC. They could tariff these differently for PVE and PVP.
I’d also like Blizz to come up with an enhanced scoring system for M+ which was reflective of skill rather than how easy it is to get carried.
DPS have a much harder time getting into a key but have a much easier time being carried (even in high keys) than those of tanks and healers
why atm, we always was after wotlk xpac
Id say warriors damage is fine, its very vulnerable without pocket healer out there tho cause lacks real defensives a la paladin.