Adding 1+1 to get 2, yes…when all you’re really doing is looking into a post, not even actively giving criticism and just throwing aimless and pointless comments of distaste, and for what reason? It’s best a forum page isn’t turned into a typical argument, instead if you have no criticism or points of improvement you believe you could offer, it’d be nice if you made a simple silent gesture, otherwise you’re just starting unneccesary feed spam which inevitably gets you nowhere, so out of kindness and consideration, if you have nothing to add on improvement or a possible friendly tip, what’s your reasoning for commenting?
2 Likes
If you mean Invader, they offered very constructive advice. For Lysandre to learn the difference between people with a functional memory or access to google, and… stalkers. Because that’s a sizely difference.
I never specificed a name, what I said was merely a comment of general means.
2 Likes
And which post inspired you to make that comment? (lol not to mention that you are literally quoting what invader is saying in your totally neutral not-in-reply-to-anyone post)
Bypassing criticism =/= “there is no criticism”
3 Likes
My point is simply that this is all completely useless in wherever it’s being taken, things have been said which are empty insults, it’s a forum for recruitment and basic information of a guild, the feeling i’m getting is that comments being made here are simply remarks of those whom are actively seeking out an online forum argument by throwing insults at another (Yes Aeilmar) It’s pointless, all I need to say. I’ve made quotes yes, but in no means have I said the quote was in any way pointless, Invader has indeed made valid points of observation…Aeilmar has simply thrown an insult of…no actual valid nature. This really doesn’t need to carry on so i’m making this my final comment in regards to the nature of this conversation.
2 Likes
I find it pretty important for potential new members to know that the guild they are contemplating joining has a habit of dying over and over, so I’d not call it useless, an empty insult, in any way irrelevant or just seeking out an online argument.
Are you saying that spreading basic awareness about the nature of the guild is insulting? Because that’s pretty, y’know, yikes.
3 Likes
I gave a very constructive and useful piece of information I would’ve thought you’d have had access to from the very beginning, but it would seem not:
3 Likes
Good luck with the guild! Glad to see some SI:7 RP back again.
1 Like
It certainly does live in Azeroth indeed, and this would doubly make sense for Kul Tiras as the ensign is also a naval flag. Ensign as a word comes from French ‘enseigne’ which is further derived from the Latin insignia - often if not always related somehow to a standard or pennant. The equivalent cavalry rank cornet is also named after the standards carried by cavalry - though this was originally derived from the horn used by Roman centuries (cornu, officer called a cornicen) as cavalry more often than not signalled using brass instruments rather than flags.
While an ensign does not always have to be related to a colour or standard, it must be noted that ensigns are officer ranks throughout history and the modern day. They most certainly do not relate to other ranks in any way, shape or form and using the term to mean ‘recruit’ is a gross anachronism.
4 Likes
It has NPCs that don’t really fit the rogue archetype that much - Kearnen is(was) just a sniper, not sure how you’re seeing her as a rogue here, Mishka is just a field medic (how is that a rogue?) and there are a few minor, but notable examples such as the SI:7 guy you have to kill during the Horde quests in Stormheim who is disguised as moonkin. If you ask me, that sounds more like a druid than a rogue. I’m sure you could find more examples in other types of media related to Warcraft, such as the books, I’m particularly familiar with those.
The point I’m trying to get across is that there’s nothing which suggests SI:7 being closed off to people who aren’t mcstabby assassin boys. I don’t really see why they’d turn down, say, a druid where they can make excellent aerial scouts or simply for the fact that they are incredibly versatile.
They’re also not objected to the idea of working together with other groups, so that’s another way of doing it in a guild/rp setting.
and yarwood never ragequited over something?
The fact that your character and the history of your guild underwent yet another change (i.e a retcon) kind of tells it away as being a reboot. I’ve tried telling this to you before you started getting rabidly dumb and crazy, but the only reasonable course of action for you now would be to do away with the character of Lysandre and the concept of this ‘Accord’ and start anew. Realise that it looks really stupid, for a lack of better word, on your character’s resume when they’re being constantly pardoned, given second chances et cetera - there’s no consistency, your character and their actions (and by extension, your guild) feel incredibly pointless since everything can be scrapped away in a few months of time, if not weeks. It just makes roleplaying with you seem like it’s going to be incredibly unrewarding, I think.
Perhaps it’s time to finally admit the hard truth that you’re either not cut out for this particular avenue of roleplay or that you’re not capable of being a guild leader. It’s okay, not everyone is, there’s no problem with that. But people who stubbornly refuse to admit that? Diffrent kind of story.
7 Likes
She’s a rogue using a gun. Sure, makes her a sniper, but her skillset is still that of a rogue.
You know, first aid used to be a profession. Might wanna look that one up. And you know what Blizzard are like giving classes to NPCs that we players can’t play as (zandalari warlocks, draenei rogues, tauren warlocks, etc)
Glyph of Disguise says hello.
You’re right - they’re not. But working WITH SI:7 =//= being a member of SI:7.
1 Like
What skillset? You can argue that she’s seen doing some light scouting in the game a few times, but most of her work piles down sitting somewhere and shooting her gun. Avoiding detection or scouting are, I think, skills that a sniper should possess anyway so I don’t really see how that makes her a rogue. Do we have a ranged spec that I missed somewhere?
??? My big brain can’t wrap its’ head around this, what is your argument here exactly?
Yes, it is a disguise, but you’ve kind of missed the mark. If the SI:7 is willing to employ a guy who disguises as an animal, why wouldn’t they recruit someone who can actually turn into them and spy on people? Who’s to say that guy wasn’t some aspiring druid who just didin’t know how to turn into a moonkin yet?
jesus christ that’s nowhere close to what i was saying
1 Like
lol
https://imgur.com/ox5aIx6
She’s a rogue.
Because a druid has very different methods and ideology to a covenant of rogues. I can’t believe I’m having to explain this.
That you can be a rogue and a field medic at the same time. Are you dumb? Don’t answer that - it’s rhetorical.
1 Like
Fair enough, Kearnen is a sniper-rogue. You got me there.
A druid can’t utilise rogue-esque tactics such as stealth and information gathering? Have you never seen someone like Thisalee Crow?
Yeah and I’m saying that you can be a rogue and a guy who can turn into an animal at the same time, it’s called a feral druid.
I think druids are free people too and they deserve equal opportunity. If they want to become a spy, I don’t think the opinion of a gnome forum poster should stop them.
nah I’m just sick and stuck at work, but thanks
1 Like
and
are distinctly not the same thing, as one either doesn’t use magic at all or uses shadow magic, and the other is a user of whatever druidism falls under. Similar =/= equal.
edit: Also
Your personal opinion is noted, appreciated, but irrelevant. SI:7 is an organization of rogues and that’s that. I’m sure someone can set up a druid spygang if druids need to be spois.
1 Like
And tell me, what faction does Thisalee Crow work for? I know the answer already, but enlighten us.
fixed that for you
1 Like
0 days since last AD elitism meltdown and Stormwind Bureau thread hijack
3 Likes
fixed that for you
5 Likes
I understand that you are trying your damnest to defend Lysandre simply because you have no clue of his past activities/you do not care/put a blind eye on that, but that doesn’t change the fact that he plagiarised IC documents of other SI:7 initiative, never admitting to that and apologising. And his inconsistency I already described in another post, so in case you missed it, Nadsie, I will link it to you again - [A-RP] <Stormwind Covert Accord> Rebooting and Recruiting - #17 by Aeílmar-argent-dawn
If you find any other “pointless insults” that I need to clarify so you could understand their nature - please tell, I will do so gladly.
5 Likes