I tried nearly all classes and specs except Evoker, DH and Monk.
Best feeling/designed for solo shuffle in my opinion:
1.Mage. I never played it before but now it is absolutely my favourite class in PvP. Just fun.
2. Hunter. Similar to Mage. MM got everything you need. Feels nice and smooth to play.
Worst:
Warrior all day. Was my main for most of time playing WoW but atm i truly hate how Arms is designed for PvP. In my opinion the most boring class/spec in the game. Feels clunky, squishy. No real defensive cds. Very average damage. Execute hits for 50% of what i can hit with Hunter’s Aimed Shot. Frost DK feels like superior version of Warrior with much better dmg.
SP. I found it to be boring since classic and nothing changed. Being focused all the time in SS. No real dispel protection. Worse version of Affi.
Feral hands down , try it and tell me how you felt playing it. not saying the ones you mentioned are bad or good but believe me , when you have so many buttons on your bars that do notting and you cant carry as hybrid class should , you will feel squishier than cloth class, all melee will catch up to you and when you will randomly drop dead ingame while 50% damage reduction up , you will question what even happend.
By the worst I would put Affli, zero visual and gameplay feedback. Bad mechanics and sheer amount of class breaking bugs ruins spec despite decent damage output.
Mage. A class that scales with skill very good which is extremely fun, always room to get better.
Disc Priest. Healing Solo Shuffle sucks but with Disc i have fun, good dmg while the gameplay is “stressless” compare to other healers.
Worst:
Ret. I loved Paladin before Dragonflight, but since the rework i just fall asleep playing this spec. Having an easy spec is fine but Ret is so easy it’s just boring.
Warrior. Class is very strong but nothing is more awful than fighting a Mage as Warrior.
Shadow. Spec is good but i dislike having zero mobility while almost everyone is zooming around.
i love play mage i try many things but just enjoy the mage gameplay specially in bg but not in arena those days maybe when frost have good damage now people calling you dogmage, you so bad your dps is to low, learn how to play… but when play arcane nobody said anything xD but as arcane you gonna eat 30 cc per second and if you find a rogue, dh, dk or hunters you literally can´t play the game and fire my fav is not playeable since dragonflight
I tried Feral and i did not like it becouse you need to have so much macros, binds, action bars and even if u are good you still feel like disabled version of Rogue. Terrible design atm but still no1 of worst/most boring is Warrior for me. I used to love this class back in classic, tbc and wotlk but now i just can’t play it. Brainless smashing 3 dmg buttons.
As a main warrior I still enjoy my class this season, fighting a mage feels like my everyday struggle to survive. Getting one tapped by mm in the opener is just a bit of adrenaline rush , being slowed ,rooted then stunned then displaced, and all over again kinda manageable. Getting kited and being nuked ? Well personally I think it feels wrong.
Arms warrior need rework on mastery.
Bleed that boost the damage they do is stupid. Feel like mastery for feral druids or assa rogues.
I liked their arms mastery in wod that boosted mortal strike , execute and colossus smash damage.
Playing warrior in solo shuffle is pure suffering, this class relies so much on teammates and if you dont have good ones it feels like ur playing without half the gear equipped, u do low dmg and evaporate on 90% of the classes pve rotation
Current version of mastery is perfect. It’s a small bleed dmg but while enemies bleeding by deep wounds they receive additional dmg equal to the percentage of mastery.
I think Rend is kind of redundancy, its just minor bleed which doesn’t always contribute to the overall dmg significantly.
Personally I love no Rend Slayer.