Imagine this: A faction that’s the majority on one realm transfers to another realm where they know they’ll be the minority.
Wait, you don’t need to imagine, that’s exactly what half the Horde on Flamelash did. So your quote doesn’t really hold up to much scrutiny and in the case of Flamelash, it seems to only apply to the Alliance.
Before the transfers, I kinda wished I was Alliance on Flamelash, then I would at least find people willing to fight. My guild opted to transfer off the server, I didn’t, even though that meant I wouldn’t see any more world PVP. You wanna know why? Because there’s a bunch of my RL friends on Flamelash who have virtually no interest in wPVP and I wasn’t going to ditch them over some people I’ve only “known” for a few months.
Even now, I don’t regret not transferring. Instead, I made the same character on ES because being outnumbered sounds like fun to me. I enjoy a challenge! I’ve told my buddies numerous times: I would much rather go into a fight I should never be able to win, than go into a fight I should never be able to lose. If I’m almost guaranteed to lose, I can only go up from there and anything will feel like a win. If I’m almost guaranteed to win, I can only go down from there and the slightest loss would be downright embarrassing. If I go up against 5 ppl by myself and I almost manage to kill one, I’ll be laughing my rear end off!
If your only interest is to get PvE content done for gear, it would seem obvious that you shouldn’t be on a PvP server. PvE content in Classic is dull as nails and to me, it’s just a necessary evil to quickly and easily get basic gear for PvP. It feels like a lot of people playing Classic see it the other way around, where PvP is considered a necessary evil, only good for getting better PvE gear.
Look, I don’t blame Alliance players for transferring when they heard the majority of their faction were going to transfer. It makes perfect sense to want to stick with your friends. But please stop with this holier-than-thou BS, and please stop pretending that the people who initiated the exodus were looking for balance. It’s quite obvious they were just looking for easy gankings, and on Flamelash, they actually had to put in effort which was just too much to ask, apparently. Instead of at least trying to face the challenge, they just rolled over and went looking for excuses.
According to your logic, Apes should have transferred off Gehennas considering it’s about the same 60/40 split in favor of the Horde. Yet, from where I’m sitting, it seems like they are thriving in this environment and they regularly stomp on everyone when they roll out. So why did they not opt for convenience? My guess is that they are also looking for a challenge and don’t want the PvP to be as dull as the PvE, where they have to invent handicaps to make it interesting…