Ok, I have here and there read about thoughts that some people want a kind of eredar, draenei-like race, so that horde could “finally” have them too in a way. Surely, lorewise it would be difficult to explain, with them first being demonic servants of the legion and then, as they were abandoned by Sargeras, why would they think: ok, we’re alone now, we need a new leader (with all that power they already have).
I am not even sure if Blizzard is going to read this after all and take it in consideration what I will write next, but let’s cross fingers and hope for that one in a million or whatever chance.
My idea is not about eredar left alone, it is rather about a kind of dispute within the draenei people on old, original draenor as in wod. And why will this make sense in the following lines below? I remember the Mag’har recruiting quest line. There you have draenei recruiting some orcs to fight aside them with the light against other orcs. SO, you could also do it the other way around, some draenei rejecting the light and fight aside the mag’har, having discovered a way stronger connection to the elements than to the light. Yes, it makes sense. Orcs have extremely powerful shamans, draenei have shamans too, so why not, lorewise? I mean, the deeper the connection to the elements becomes, the further it might take this special part of the draenei away from the light… Considering intertribal disputes within other races, this can happen to draenei too. A part of differently believing Draenei also makes sense from another point of view, comparing them with the night elves. Think of how the nightborne came to be. The nightborne were those city dwelling nightelves, who embraced magic more than the druidism of their more inland-living relatives.
So, I imagine Draenei live everywhere, including the shores of Draenor. This part of the draenei people, having villages at the waters, does not only live at it, but on it too, they have kind of “fallen in love” with the sea. The dispute with their brethren was about using normal magic and the elements instead of the light. Their extensive practice of shamanism came from intense contact with some orcish clans. These sea folk draenei were convinced, that they would not need the naaru anymore, living mainly on or at the dark, wide waters. They kept on focusing more on the elemental ways, becoming even more powerful shamans. The elements and normal magic would just help them better out on the dark oceans, when they were navigating through the waves to discover these vast expanses.
Since I have no idea about draenei language because of the lack of dictionaries, I just call this “tribe” seafolk.
This would also explain, why their draenei cousins were slowly forgetting them, not mentioning them anymore in their chronicles and history writing, just like as with a dispute within a family, where one does not want to have to do anything with the others anymore.
As they were living on the dark waters, their bodies began to change, giving them darker skin in comparison to their kin, as adaption to the all times present sunlight. As time went by, they lived their lives in peace. Until this one day. At the horizon, they saw a strange, green light. They were curious, what it could have been, navigating their ships towards it. After many years at sea, they set foot on land again, yet, they were not welcome by their other land-living draenei relatives. In fact, there was still enormous disdain to be seen from them, they never forgave the seafolk for giving up the naaru. With a heavy heart, they set sail again, looking for the only other people, they last knew being friendly towards them: The Mag’har orcs. Luckily, this tribe of orcs still kept on following the old ways, not having forgotten who the seafolk actually were within their hearts: peace-loving shamans of the sea. From these orcs, the seafolk got to hear that some of the other orc tribes began working together with demons, and some others again were forming a nonetheless still hostile resistance, the iron horde. Nothing the mag’har and their friends, the frostwolf clan, wanted to have to do something with. Soon, the conflict began to threaten whole draenor, and thus also the life of the seafolk. As their kin did reject them, they saw no other way than to side with the orc clans who refused to join the demons or the iron horde. After some time, they met a powerful mage called Khadgar, leading a resistance against the the demonic and iron savages. After a long time, when the demons and iron horde were finally driven back, the seafolk heard, that their old mag’har friends wanted to connect with orcish friends in the world were Khadgar came from. First, they were hesitant, because it was about leaving their world and going to places unknown. But after long years of consideration and discussing, they too sent some ambassadors of their people to where the mag’har ambassadors went, offering to fight aside the horde in return for having helped them against the demons and the evil iron orc clans. They arrive in a world where the horde is no longer led by a warchief, instead a council of leaders making decisions. But still, they see familiar things in the Horde city, Orgrimmar. Shamanism as they have been heavily embracing it over the years at sea and shore, is also part of the new Horde.
Classes that would make sense at this constellation would be: Warrior, (death knight), hunter, shaman, rogue, mage. No paladins and priests for these draenei, since they abandoned the light. Instead, the shadows of the sea gave them the power to become rogues!
I have no idea if Blizzard will take this seriously, but this seems like a better explanation to me how the horde get a kind of draenei without meaning demonic eredar.