dont really fit together now do they. But I will ignore it for now, GDKP community is not even close to the same as a properly functioning guild, a GDKP community is literally a community formed around people wanting to maximize their profit/progression nothing in the concept of GDKP is in any way shape or formed geared towards helping people out.
And thats really good of you to do I do the same thing but not because people leave when they see my char but because I seek out the once that need that bit of help.
Easiest way to get those groups going is by basicly applying marketing strategies, “LFM Arca HC come and kick the stupid AQ bosses butt while having a easy time” there you go you have a msg that instantly will give you a higher chance of people wanting to join than “LF 2 DPS 1 H Arca HC” would ever give you.
I know the pain because Im the one that offer people the help with those things, I dont in any way abuse my contacts if I need anything, first I ask in guild if anyone is at all interested in joining what ever, might throw in a please help me finally get that trinket or what ever if people know I have been going for something for a while, and I usually get at least 1 response, then I check with people I have helped a lot outside my guild if they might want to tag along, and then I go into the chat and look for people usually have a full group within a few min of posting in the chat. No “enslavement” no “abuse” just asking for a favor not in any way shape or form actually feeling entitled to it.
Like I said I dont actually completely fill most of my group with only guild members.
As a tank it would be the same even without a guild, wow have always been lacking tanks for 5 man content also been to a lesser extent lacking healers but not even close to the same. Having something make things go quicker and with less need to apply any social skills at all would be bad for the game in the long run though, we have seen where that leads. If they would do something like they do with flying in retail (where its locked for off completely for the first patch or 2) I wouldnt be fighting against it because its the beginning of a expansion where most new or returning players actually come and thats when its important that they see the social structures they have to chose from, be it that they chose GDKP communitys and get pressured into buying gold at least to begin with so they can get the gear so they can earn the gold later or be it into a actual guild that have those social elements some of us actually mostly play this game for.
Its not that we will suffer its that we will have a lesser chance of showing people something other than the “I need this item now now now” mentality that is infecting this game.