It looks more and more like "You think you do, but you dont!" wasn't that far off

I know its always easy upvotes to s***t on J. Allen Brack for his comment on wanting Classic servers, but it really starts to feel like he was right.

Maybe if he had worded it like

“You think you want Classic, but you dont, because the true Classic experience will never return and Classic servers would be plagued by exploiters, hardcore min-maxers and a toxic community.”

people would have not ridiculed him for it. Because thats exactly whats happening right now.

And before you post “BUT ON MY RP PVP REALM EVERYTHING IS FINE AND NICE!”, yeah great, but you arent representing the majority of the playerbase.

25 Likes

Sure, if he always does what no one wants, and never listens, it is the players fault.

2 Likes

He was ridiculed for the sheer arrogance that comes with a statement like that. But humans will always find the path of least resistance and take the easy way out - even if it involves cheating or exploiting and that will never change.

I think I do and I still do :slight_smile:

13 Likes

The problem is classic not being like Vanilla. This ends up changin the feeling and behavior of the community too.

… Just stop.

2 Likes

You could never, never ever, return to the roots. Even without layering there would have been people crashing the economy, using exploits and scummy tactics.

5 Likes

Maybe not, but this was neither what he said, nor what he meant.

He talked about having to find groups in /2 or /LookingForGroup. The literally FIRST EXAMPLE he gave for why he thought “ytydbyd”, was a QoL feature. He wasn’t even considering any community aspects, in fact his first example is a QoL feature that removed community interactions.

Sorry, I know you mean well, but you are giving this guy a credit he doesn’t deserve, not by a long shot.

11 Likes

Nope.

Without bugs and changes this would be much more harder than it is right now and very time consuming.

Just nope. Im off this forum, im tired.

2 Likes

The simple solution was a remake instead of a re-release of an old product.
Well, they won’t listen. So, we don’t and the loop turns infinite.

The major part of why classic can’t be what vanilla was is that even if we ignore the mechanical differences/bugs in the game client itself, everything else has changed so much. And most of all, we have changed. People playing MMO’s today are completely different in how they interact with a game than we were back in 2004. The mysteries are (mostly) all exposed and readily available online. And even if you try to be strict with yourself – as I did – just the knowledge that the answer to any question is a simple search away changes everything.

5 Likes

And he was still right.

Its absurdly hard to find groups in /lookingforgroups except if you want to spellcleave and rush dungeons.

You think you want Classic way of building groups, but you dont, because it will be exclusionary as hell.

-Hey, i want classic!
-Sure!

  • released an abomination on legion engine full of bugs and exploits -

-Meh, i dont like that
-I told you, you think u do, but you dont!
-but thats not classic ?
-i toooold youuuu

/facepalm

probably if these ladies could have made a proper beta test instead of streamer 40 lvl dueling crap we can have a nice woeking game people wont vomit in sight ?

14 Likes

That isn’t what he said or what he meant. Besides yourself and any other retail player, is there anyone here who didn’t think he was referring to how comfortable and dependent we now are with LFG/LFR/Shorter HS etc etc etc.

This whole layering situation is ridiculous for sure, but espeially because if it wasnt for the forums and streams, 99% of the player base would be completely and entirely oblivious to it’s happening and would still be enjoying the game (they probably are anyway actually)

I am still having more fun than I have in years and even the knowledge that there are some cheating buggers out there, doesn’t really detract from it for me.

I don’t understand your constant shizzing on this game katreena, even now you’re having to put words in his mouth to give credibility to the statement. Just stop playing it, or stop spewing your literally endless negativity haha

5 Likes

Many complaints are due to balance, classic “features” or similar. Just take a second to look through this forum.

Warriors should get the dps from sunder armor

When can we start talking about balance?

And those two are just from the first few seconds I spent browsing.

People are complaining about missing QoL features that weren’t in classic, they’re complaining about missing balance, which they knew (or should’ve known) about and so on.

Yes, the bugs, exploits and similar indeed diminish ones personal enjoyment, but I don’t think people are referring to those players complaining about bugs and exploits, but rather to those that are complaining about classic being classic.

1 Like

Exactly what its happening. “Retail” “”""“fixes”"""" made classic project a huge mess overall and EVERYBODY from classic told them that.

People are just… well Ill better shut my mouth but their logic is as dead as retails writters.

they cant even copy an old game properly for god sake.

Yes, I feel quite dependent on an LFG Tool right now, because I refuse to rush dungeons, which leads to people either leaving, not even joining or kicking me from groups. I cant even enjoy the game when I want to do a dungeon because I know I will have to spend at least 2 hours searching for suitable players. Thats not fun.

No its not?! Tanks, healers find groups pretty fast…ofc you will have problems finding groups, you play dps class, which is available in huge numbers…

Even as a healer. Try joining a group as a healer then not healing anyone that is rushing and taking aggro from the tank. You will get kicked in an instant.

Seriously, I can’t even find a single group for any dungeon since lvl 28. Every group now is just spellcleave spams with tactics they can’t pull off. You end up wiping each pack because the puller can’t understand that if we couldn’t do that 25-mob pull 3 minutes ago we can’t do it now. Eventually you get less xp than as if you were solo grinding in the open world.

1 Like

You will, if you’re in a spell/meleecleave group. If not, you won’t. Learn to not group with elitist morons.

You are playing on bad realm full of elitists wannabe hardcore kids. PvP realms always attract bad players.

I have no such issues on HW and there are no cleave groups. Its as close to vanilla experience as it can get. Realm is full of older players who just want to have fun, not rushing, not cheesing, not exploiting. And guess what - we are having lots of fun.

3 Likes