Well it’s all a very personal, and financial choice. If you’re not feeling any issues on the realm, then I’m certainly not advocating leaving. Especially currently, when there is no incentive to move (ie, no character transfer sale on … plus no ability to transfer your guild).
You never know, Blizzard might surprise everyone and open up free transfers in a couple of months time
We had spent months discussing the move, before we even decided to move. We then researched all the other realms that we thought were a “good fit”, made alts and checked them out day to day, played on them during the big patch day recently, made a google form to get everyone’s option and, more importantly, to ensure that, if we did move, we’d have a good sized guild still afterwards. Inevitably some don’t want to move, or don’t reply, so you have to take that into account.
We were working towards a move date sometime in summer, as normally Blizzard has a sale around that time, including transfers, but then they announced the new bulk transfers and the sale, so we just decided to take advantage and do it there and then. Not realising, initially, that the ability to actually transfer the guild itself had been removed from the store. And then we were told some rubbish about Blizzard looking to fix it “as a priority”, and we fell for it. Decided to transfer anyway, assuming that, within days, we’d be able to transfer the guild over.
In summary … transferring a guild is hard work Not helped, at all, by Blizzard putting a spanner in the works, and then being misleading about a fix.
But I’ve had several messages back from guild members, some of whom were reluctant to move but wanted to remain with us, who are really pleased we did move. And personally, I’ve been quite surprised at how many did transfer with us.