I suppose there’s the answer then. The more one expands, the more friction they will have both from the inside (more people with different opinions) and on the outside (other guilds that see PCU guilds moving in on their turf, or that simply have as their members people with negative experiences). But this is a problem unique to a vast, trully massive, community that the PCU is, IMO, and its natural. Now is it worth it? Face it the PCU could sustain a server on their own, but most new RPers, and new characters, will crop up in Argent Dawn, so for the sake of growth and variety, one can argue that yes, it is worth the pain.
We already do 
34 Likes
I don’t. It works really, really well. We have very few arguments and the RP we do together is second to none in terms of quality.
4 Likes
You can tell that better than I, all I have are hypothesis.
Thesis… Synthesis… Antithesis…
5 Likes
The bear, the bull, the bear, the bull …
9 Likes
The P… The C… And the U…
3 Likes
The reason is in their take with people. They have a very heavy focus on their own community over others, usually denying or shaving off criticism of any kind.
It’s kind of obvious when there are conflicts this strategy won’t make people like them, especially when if their attitude wasn’t great to begin with.
5 Likes
Yeah the people don’t like us
t. 171 people online rn
6 Likes
Issue probably lies with the attitude some of the members have (or have had?). People can indeed change and it’s nice they’re trying but it takes time to get rid of bad impressions and I think that’s why various people dislike said community rather than it being the cliche ‘jealousy’. But as said time and time again, don’t judge a whole on the bad apples.
2 Likes
170 more than the competition
10 Likes
Many don’t. And many do. I’m sure both have good and based reasons.
imo 171 for what, 11 guilds (?) is a good number, but not that impressive.
1 Like
Is your argument that 171 only counts as impressive if the Rotgarde has that online on its own ? You are giving Perroy dark ideas rn I like it
Come off it though, we will soon go beyond 200 and you will say the same still
8 Likes
Cope: the post
8 Likes
Yeah. 200 isn’t a lot: that’s 20 people per guild. Go to 500 with 11 guilds and I will find that impressive. Look at it this way: I could gather 10/15 people per event with very niche concepts. 170 for 11 wide-concept guilds at peak hours isn’t mind-blowing, it’s all I am saying.
But it’s good that you like your community though.
2 Likes
Sure you could, it’s good that you have confidence
4 Likes
In a sense that’s true because you have the exact same faculties as for example myself or Morsteth so in theory you can absolutely do that but the truth is you won’t ever / can’t so this big post’s claim a pure “uhhh yeah I can do this I just decide not to” cope
Prove me wrong if you think you can. I would be very seriously surprised if you could run a single guild with an average activity of 10 players for even a couple of months
2 Likes
I already did? I made guilds back then.
It’s not about me or you or Morsteth. It’s just that having 15 people online per guild isn’t an exceptional number.
2 Likes
You’re allowed to critique it’s just we can critique back. Don’t know why that’s an outrageous concept.
10 Likes
Get several guilds doing that, in a solid community. Then we’ll talk.
4 Likes