No Warcraft without Christianity

add brigante to that list xD (or replace by)

“wokescold” is a pejorative used to describe someone who scolds others for lacking a certain level of knowledge about social issues.

1 Like

True facts, that is even worse than text based communication, I mean, useful at it’s time, but I wouldn’t exactly use it to send a message to the other half…!

I mean, I am nearing 50 at an alarming rate, but I prefer to think of myself as still mid 40’s, I think I have one year left until I have to submit to the depressing reality that I am in fact late forties, at which point I need to acquire a smoking jacket, a pipe, a subscription to The Times, and a map of the world where most of it is painted pink, possibly a shotgun and a pair of hunting hounds…

Interesting. It perhaps means something else to the older generations, but generally using the word ‘woke’ is seen as a sign of immaturity and political naivety. But hey, every day we learn something new, I shall add that to my vocabulary. Who am I kidding, I shall do so, and then forget it when talking to fair maidens in Nightclub’s of repute. Probably whilst slurring. Or being sick. Or trying to fight a statue.

I wouldn’t say that Warcraft has a dependency on Christianity. It’s clear that the early games were full of such references and inspiration, but as the universe has evolved over the years, many more influences have come along. Nordic, Chinese, Greek etc. I still believe that there are bits of Christianity left over and will most likely remain for the rest of the franchise’s life. They may have washed over it to make it more ambiguous, but it’s still there, it would be very hard to erase it from the Church of the Light for example since that itself is very much inspired by the organisation of Christianity we know today.

It’s okay to base things on Christian tales and folklore, and doing so does not exclude or alienate people of different faiths or of none.

I’d encourage Blizzard to go further, as they use to in the past, and incorporate other religions and cultures. Take tasteful inspiration. Blizzard today does do this, Ardenweald is full of Irish folklore. But I feel like perhaps to be perceived as woke, they’ve deviated away from portraying forces such as the Light in their original, human-centric Christian-inspired perspective.

I wouldn’t even say they’ve done that to be woke to be honest. There are people in the woke crowd who follow the Christian faith, and Christianity is not always at odds with progressive values, so whether they stick to the Light’s Christian roots or deviate from them, either way it’s no indication of wokeness.

If anything, the change is probably to make it feel more distinct as an in-universe religion rather than a simple homage or even copy of the real-world Christian faith.

1 Like

I will shame the crap out of my autism every day of the week and you can’t stop me.

Yes.

1 Like

Fair point, but you can make it unique without pasting over older lore I feel. For example Tyr’s significance in the human faith, they pretty much glossed over it in Legion as just a way to get the Holy paladin artefact. It was more about him being a Titan Keeper than a religious icon.

As for the ‘woke’ thing. I guess the knee-jerk reaction these days is to assume the worst, and the reason behind all this is so the big corporation doesn’t offend, else the potential market shrinks.

I think sometimes it isn’t religion as such, as age. People who use the term ‘Woke’ tend to be of the younger generation, now people who use the term can be applying it amongst themselves, but also can be applying it to people of the previous generation, ( I don’t think actual Boomers would care at all about it :stuck_out_tongue: ) Let us leave aside for a moment that the term ‘Woke’ and it’s derivatives is an absolute infantile and nonsensical use of language, and get back on track here.

You have various religious influences in WoW as someone pointed out just above, some of which predate Christianity to a large degree. I mean you have Titans, which were ancient Greek, I mean that -is- where we get the word from, you have Nordic/Saxon deities in there which we encounter in Northrend, so again, another religion system that predates Christianity, Ardenweald is heavily Celtic religion slanted, I mean you have Herne the Hunter and one of the Groves named after Tir Na Nog, which is -literally- the Celtic faith’s afterlife! Again, a religious system that predates Christianity. Tauren faith belongs to a religion that predates Christianity (Anyone who has seen the film ‘A man called Horse’ can testify to that, the Sun and the Moon were very important to them, massively so religiously, so that would be An’she and Mu’sha then. Again, predates Christianity. The Concept of Loa, again, predates Christianity. So really, to say that Christianity needs to be in the game is more an aspect of ego, rather than logic. It’s basically ‘My Sky Daddy is more important than your Sky Daddy’ Which is never a good look.

Let’s remember here, that if you are bringing Christianity into the game, you are bringing two other religions into it also. You are bringing Judaism into it, because after all, Joshua ben Joseph, or Jesus as they call him now, -was- Jewish. He was never Christian, by definition there was no Christian faith until after his death. You are also introducing Islam into the game, because Jesus, the pivotal point of the Christian faith, was also revered as a prophet by the Muslim religion! (fun fact, Jesus is mentioned favourably in the Qu’ran 4 times as much as Mohammed is) I really don’t see this as being helpful, and would if anything be insulting to three religions, when they could just -not- be insulting to them?

Truth be told, the current compassionate, altruistic and noble Titans are gods that are seen and interpreted with the lens of christianity - perfect, benevolent gods unable to conceive anything evil, and whose existence brings order to creation.

Even the idea of the titans as rational beings isn’t the typical conception of the Greek gods.

I would add this is more of a New Testament upgrade than the whole of Christianity. The Old Testament is absolutely full of stories about both God and his chosen followers bringing chaos, war, and death to the world.

Come to think of it, it’s the figure of Jesus that many have come to associate with Christianity which many Christians encourage since the teachings of Jesus are much more palatable to us and our modern day sensibilities than someone like Moses going WorldStar on his own people for the great offense of losing faith.

People joke about Green Jesus (Thrall) but his story and role being that of a messiah brought a good balance of seriousness and comic hero cool to the world of Azeroth. There is a reason he used to be one of the most recognized faces of the franchise, along with Arthas.

2 Likes

True, although a lot of that isn’t so much a telling of his deeds, as it is hammering down the idea that he shoudn’t be considered God.

I didn’t know this before; but there was actually a fairly popular early Christian sect called Marcionism. They believed that the benevolent God as shown in the NT is an entirely seperate (and superior) diety to the more violent, callous and mercurial God from the OT.
Obiviously they thought that NT God was the true one, and OT God was not.

(I realize neither of these points has much to do with the original topic… But as a former Religious Studies student, I take every opportunity I can to nerd out about these things!)

Oh, yes, absolutely. I agree on that bit!

I didn’t mind Thrall, but I think his Cataclysm storyline wasn’t one of his strong points.

Here is humanity represented by western culture… and here is the rest of the world represented by this cacophony of monsters.

:blush:

3 Likes

Very true, he is a Prophet, but equally the same is true of Mohammed, it is emphatically stated that he is not God either, just the newest (and last, in that faith’s) prophet.

However…

Wow! You Nerd out on it! That is fascinating, I too had a Religious Studies education and I never heard of that Sect, That is some mad level stuff, So if they saw the NT God, as different to the OT God, which makes sense, I can dig that, as they do seem to have differing standpoints, to a massive degree, then how did that then work with The Adversary? Was it some weird triad or something? Which actually if you think about it, could make a lot of sense.

I’m pretty sure Western culture is perfectly capable of spawning it’s own monsters, like, massively famously so…

2 Likes

ik ik, I was just taking a small jab at eurocentric fantasy design.

3 Likes

Heh, fair enough! :smiley:

1 Like

I find Gnosticism (of which Marcionism seems to be a variant?) to be pretty interesting too; it’s an interesting way they tried to explain the discrepancies between the Old and New Testament God.

3 Likes

shoutout to my boy Mani

1 Like

Gnosticism came in lots of great and tasty flavours for the masses, so it wouldn’t surprise me if Marcionism came out of it or was influenced by that kind of mix of early Christian doctrine and Greek enlightenment.

Didn’t spend a huge amount of time on it during my theology degree, sadly, despite it being very interesting.

3 Likes