Final Fantasy XIV is not a good game. It’s the definition of “ok, you can copy my homework. just change it a bit.”
The story is really boring “chosen one” through the vanilla experience, which by the way, they force you through with a raid finder-esque series of group finder experiences, that are all mandatory.
PvP is even more of a joke than it’s ever been in WoW. I don’t think you can find anyone committed to it in FF and for good reasons too.
GCD at 2.5 to compensate for the console players is awful. On paper it sounds like a minuscule difference, but trust me it’s instantly noticeable The off-gcd abilities feel like patting and generally speaking, the class (job) design is terrible and even more dumbed down than modern WoW. By a lot too.
Graphically, FF14 is void of identity unlike WoW and can easily be compared to GW2, Lineage or any korean mmo. It all kind of bleeds together when it’s this generic.
Zero incentive to team up and socialize as a byproduct of said teamwork. Just like wow, not worse, but definitely not better either.
The lore is weak and there’s basically no correlation between races and classes like wow. I can think of maybe one exception (the warrior class) but that’s it.
Result is that there’s less of an identity to the classes. Same with races. They have a flavor text, but there’s actually zero cohesion between the world and its races. They are just kind of there.
Oh and if you thought the hero class requirements are bad for wow, wait until you try this mmo. The insane amount of grinding you have to undergo to play the newer classes is honestly insulting. Imagine WoW’s allied race + heritage armor grind combined and you have something that is somewhat close to representing it.
All in all, a mediocre wow clone with a famous franchise tag slapped on it for good measure. Highly discourage disenfranchised wow players to waste their money on this discount mmo.