No i havn’t really been following you, gotta admit that.
Look, seems like your issue is, you believe, that pvp is not a separate progression, it’s simply a small mini game in Wow that should be accessible to anyone at anytime, no matter what they do in the game.
And that is just not the case, sorry. And it never will be. Unless blizz decides to delete a huge portion of their playerbase for no reason.
When you go to your mythic raids, your mythic dungeons, you progress your gear.
Pvpers do the same but in pvp. They run their bgs, their arenas, they push their rating.
You both get separate gear, for your separate effort within your separate progression path.
If you wanna pvp, you start from scratch, the entry pvp gear.
If i wanna pve, i start from scratch aswell, probably the heroic gear or something, depends how blizz decides to go here.
If i enter your mythic raid with my pvp gear, you will stomp my hps if i heal, my dps if i dps and the boss will stomp my behind if i try and tank.
As it should be.
Likewise, the players will stomp you, if you decide to enter pvp with your pve gear.
Why should there be any difference?
And they won’t get scaling back, it got removed in pre patch because everyone hated it. And again, they cannot find a true balance between how fast you get gear in pvp vs in pve. Because you cannot balance player skill and npc skill to find an exact balance in gear progression.
And i also don’t understand why you expect to be a challenging contestant in a area you never entered, because you did content that has nothing to do with said thing you wanna do?