I am going to lecture you a little bit here, because I don’t think you appreciate the story for what it fundamentally was written to be.
Like I said, The Horde are the underdogs in the story. Metzen, who wrote the story, basically inserted himself into the personification of the underdog in Warcraft – Thrall. The slave that broke free and saved the repressed Orcs from the internment camps and sailed east to the forgotten lands of Kalimdor and fought for and founded the lands of The Horde.
I mean, Thrall may as well be called George Washington. And Kalimdor is America. The geography and layout and everything, it’s all there! The Tauren are the native Americans!
The story of The Horde breaking free from the demon influence and settling in the harsh lands of Durotar and forming a union with the Tauren and the Trolls is very much a story inspired by the American war of independence. It’s almost the only story Metzen knows how to tell, because he kind of told it in StarCraft as well where he also inserted himself into the underdog character of Jim Raynor who’s up against The Terran Confederacy who’s logo even looks like the American Confederate flag.
Point being that the story theme of The Horde is that of the underdog reflecting American history. It’s a story of struggle, fighting for one’s independence and values and right to be.
It’s an American story. It’s why so many players find the Horde appealing, because it’s story themes taken from their own cultural history.
The Alliance on the other hand, are King Arthur and his Knights of the Round Table.
The appeal of The Alliance is the same as the story of King Arthur, the knights and castles and the nobility and righteousness and the quest for good, and the virtue of justice in the face of unspeakable evil.
That’s Arthas and Uther and Lothar and Turalyon and Anduin and everyone else in The Alliance. They’re all shaped around the mould of King Arthur and Lancelot and Tristan and…Uther. They’re variations of him and his knights that Metzen have written his own spins on.
Obviously the draw here is the struggle to hold onto your virtues when faced with hardship. Arthas falls, Anduin struggles, and Lothar dies heroically. It’s different knights’ tales.
To ask for Blizzard to put The Horde and The Alliance into a blender and make a smoothie out of them and treat them exactly the same, and everyone one side gets something the other side should get something similar, is to not appreciate the story for how it was fundamentally written.
I think there’s a lot of criticism for how Blizzard have evolved the factions over the years in World of Warcraft, but I think you’re doing the Warcraft story a disservice by not appreciating it for what it is. The Alliance often gets the grand hero scenes, because their story is the knight’s tale. The Horde often gets the story of sacrifice and struggle, because their story is the American story.
USA! USA! USA!