Why does Classic look so much better than Retail?

It doesnt look better. Its objectively worse but, if thats your opinion then thats fine.
Its ok to be wrong.

6 Likes

Itā€™s clearly an opinion that I think the game looks better?

I would refer you to the last part of my comment :slight_smile:

Just because it is clear to you, doesnā€™t mean it is for the recipient of your message. And when almost everyone interprets your thread as questioning why classic looks better rather than sharing your opinion, you may need to reflect on that.

3 Likes

Ok - I will add (OPINION) bold and underlined next time I want to share my opinion so as not to offend anyone :wink:

Iā€™m not mad at all. And you assuming so made it personalā€¦in case you didnā€™t realize.

Anyways, Iā€™d recommend you to look up the requirements for a decent discussion; itā€™s all about supportive arguments. You base an opinion on arguments, only then an opinion can be discussed.

Now look at your own used arguments, and your own opinion formed based on these arguments. It makes absolutely no sense. Which, again, is fineā€¦but itā€™s not much of an discussion-worthy opinion other than just a preference; fine. I have mine, you have yours. But from a discussion perspective this topic is below 0.

5 Likes

Ok mate, next time Iā€™ll write a thousand word thesis to support an incoming ā€˜argumentā€™ from you :rofl:

1 Like

Itā€™s not about offending people. I just wanted to give my two cents, considering you seem to want to have a discussion, but all you are met with is people confused as to how you can claim Classic looks better when itā€™s false.

But again, seeing how you respond, I donā€™t think any discussion would lead to anything other than you refusing anything that doesnā€™t align with ā€œyour opinionā€ :slight_smile: gl!

3 Likes

Nobody needs a thousand word thesis with supportive arguments. Exaggerating is another red flagā€¦

But, if you use as argument that Classic is more detailed, giving shoulder pads as example, then that point can be discussed - no? And this is very objective; it either is, or isnā€™t. What you could argue is that the level of detail suits the game more, or something like that.

1 Like

Maybe you have texture resolution set at higher in classic client than in TWW client.

2 Likes

really do i need to give u Glasses? Classic doesnt look better then Retail, let me guess u never played Classic before now? that will explain the honeymoon feeling.

This reminds me of

8 Likes

https://imgur.com/a/mus7GF5

3 Likes
2 Likes

Classic looks better? I donā€™t think so

Each to their own I guess.

13 Likes

And rain! Rain in vanilla is so much better than in retail.

4 Likes

Classic wow just has a very iconic look

4 Likes

Perhaps itā€™s that Uncanny Valley where the more realistic something feels creepy / not quite right somehow. Until it reaches almost perfect levels of realism (thatā€™s why itā€™s a valley, it dips in the middle).

So Classic had quite stylised graphics (some call it cartoonish but thatā€™s being a bit mean) which arenā€™t really trying to be realistic.
Over the years theyā€™ve increased the realism and it may be dipping into that Valley.

Iā€™m just guessing.

It also just be that current hardware can render the older graphics so much better.

In case youā€™re talking about the new faces specifically the problem here is that the old faces were basically just textures meaning that it was far easier to give each face a different personality.

When they swapped to the newer models the bodies improved significantly for the most part but the head / face almost had a downgrade of sorts because they failed to give each new face the same distinct look. The difference is that the newer faces are actual models and the features are distinguished by the MESH itself rather than the texture(though texture / material also helps). Theoretically it is an improvement.

It is unfortunate, I often preferred the older faces too. Their art team did a great job with the bodies but yeah, the faces feel more like an unfinished and unpolished student project almost rather than a proper feature considering WoWā€™s and Blizzardā€™s standards and ageā€¦ I still remember how many of the folks on the forums acted like children who were disappointed with their christmas present. Their characters no longer seemed to portray the same personality and vibe as before. I cant blame them, they sort of ruined the characters for me too but I have gotten used to it now and its hard to go back to the lower resolution texture only faces.

2 Likes

Maybe your retail game has some shenaningan resolution like 800x600 and then it looks even uglier and less details than the very very very old very pixeled classic :man_shrugging:

1 Like

That I can agree with though. Wetlands during a rainstorm was really amazing.