Before I reply, let me clarify I don’t care what others play. They can play Pikachu or Ronald McDonald. I don’t care. In fact I think the time, I cared is long gone by now.
However I think this friction is mainly Blizzards fault and their obsession to balance the Horde population.
I don’t care for faction balance.
The Horde had less players during Vanilla period and I was perfectly happy with that.
In fact it was kind of fun trying to make a more humanoid race.
The Forsaken was because of this aspect the most played race on the Horde.
Basically they were dead Humans.
Let’s analyse the races that were introduced on the Horde since the very first expansion:
Blood Elves
Goblins
Pandaren
Nightborne
Highmountain Tauren
Mag’Har Orcs
Zandalari Trolls
Vulpera
Dracthyr
Blood Elves are basically High Elves with green eyes.
They are a civilized, beautiful race, very close to human appearance, in fact the 3 Windrunner sisters are married/in a relationship with Humans, even if one of them is a undead.
This race fits the Alliance perfectly. In fact had they been given to the Alliance in TBC, there was no need to introduce Void Elves in BFA.
The very same reasoning can be applied to the Nightborne. They are basically the NEs allied race.
Pandaren are civilized, peaceful, wise, funny people. Again another good match for the Alliance.
Vulpera fall in to the same category, with the bonus that they are cute, charming, lovely.
Dracthyr fall in to the same category as the Pandaren in my opinion. They should be given to only one Faction. Horde or Alliance.
Of course every race is welcomed to the Horde. Thrall said himself in Vanilla:
“All members of the Horde are equal in my eyes, (player name).
We have suffered many burdens, and if it were not for wisdom and honor, then we would no better than the scourge or my people while our blood was tainted by the demon Mannoroth.
It is your duty to aid the Horde and to defend our way of life.
But it is also your duty to know when quarter and compassion should be given to friend and foe alike.
Understand this well.
This is the new Horde, not some demon-sapwned army who lack free will.”
However, Blizzard writers made abundantly clear during every single faction conflict, who was at fault: the Horde.
Any reasoning falls flat on the ground considering that Garrosh and his followers were turned in Raid bosses during MoP.
Sylvanas was also a Raid boss during SL.
The results of villain batting the Horde are:
-
Theramore: destroyed by a mana bomb.
Probably the inspiration for this event can be associated with a weapon of mass destruction: nuclear bomb.
-
Novel War Crimes, written by Christie Golden. Clearly inspired in the trials of Nuremberg after WW2 ended.
-
Burning of Teldrassil. Can be associated to many sad moments in human history. Particularly what happened in the Eastern Front during WW2.
-
Siege of Undercity, the use of blight to kill Alliance troops can be related to WW1 chemical warfare. Also disregard for friendly fire, killing their own troops in the process.
Now let’s associate said actions with the races, I mentioned above.
For me, it simply doesn’t make sense.
Heck even Baine and his Tauren wouldn’t make sense, in this events.
Is it any surprise people consider the Horde a Warmongering, brutal faction in both sides ?
That some races don’t make sense joining this faction given their track record ?
Cheers.