I have watched your video. Here’s my response.
You make precisely six points in favour of the boost, and they are all variations of the same arguments we’ve all read many times in the various forum posts.
Your arguments all boil down to the following:
1 The game is already ‘different’, so adding changes such as boosts ultimately makes no difference.
2 The old world is already ‘ruined’ due to the boosting meta, therefore it does not matter if it is further ruined by the 58 boost.
3 It’s only one character, and therefore not a big issue.
4 It will ensure Outland has a large population on dead servers.
5 Some people don’t like Classic levelling, therefore it’s fine to allow them to skip it.
6 A very confusing straw man remark along the lines of “anti-boosters say they wanted Classic WoW only because there is no cash shop, but there are lots of other reasons for Classic WoW, therefore a cash shop is fine”.
1 You do not elaborate the way in which the game is ‘different’ from Classic, you simply say it ‘in passing’, without qualifying the statement.
Even if the game really is ‘different’, how does this justify a level boost?
They changed the formula for Pepsi a few years ago, but does that justify them putting rat poison into it?
2 Two wrongs don’t make a right. Even if the old world truly is ‘ruined’, ‘made empty’, or othewise affected due to the Mage boost meta how will making it even more empty via level boosts do anything except make the situation worse?
You have identified that a thing is broken, and your proposed solution is ‘break it more’.
3 It may be only one character, but there are hundreds of thousands of characters playing WoW Classic. The effect is cumulative. The problem with the boost is the boost itself, not the number of boosters.
4 It may ensure Outland has a large temporary population, but would this really be any different if there were no boost? We all know that Outland will be busy for a few weeks, maybe a month-or-so, before settling down, just like Classic.
Classic had no boost and the zones in the first few weeks were all busy.
On the other hand, what if the boost ensures that the Old World is empty? Not everyone uses Mage boosting - in fact I’m pretty confident that it’s only a minority of people who do.
5 Since when has catering to the lowest common denominator, and pandering to instant gratification been good game design? What good has ever come of this?
We all saw what this kind of thinking did to Retail. You admit that those who say they ‘don’t have time’ are talking bullcorn, and that what they really mean is ‘I can’t be bothered with this’. How is pandering to this mindset ever going to bring a positive result?
6 This one was very confusing. You seemed to say that people who campaigned for WoW Classic did so ‘only because there was no cash shop’, ignoring the myriad other reasons we wanted WoW Classic, of which no cash shop was a relatively minor thing on a long list.
But you then go on to actually list many of the real reasons we wanted WoW Classic, claiming them as your own reasons; and somehow use this to justify a belief that giving us a cash shop is not important, because our reasons for wanting WoW Classic were not as important as your reasons - ignoring the fact that we all share the same reasons.
Nope, it makes even less sense when I type it out.
So there you go.