I see it the same way, honestly. (Thanks for the link)
I donât think that anyone is making arguments against any of theseâŚ
I may be missing something, but I cannot recall Blood Elves NPCs having further canonical light themed options aside from the golden eyes we already have?
You mentioned light themed options on the Blood Elf customization thread as well, but if I understand correctly these are something youâd LIKE to be implemented, and BECOME canon, rather than something the NPCs already have / a cinematic shows and the character creator is missing.
So to me it feels like âred eyesâ and âlight optionsâ (if I remember correctly you suggested glowing skins?) are just two different proposals for future race/lore development.
But even though you have a point that it is only undead elves that have the red eyes in-game, blood elf glowing skins have never been shown⌠so between the two, the second proposal seems weirder to me.
Sure, we see in the lore that different magic energies shape all creatures, but ainât arcane and light magic exactly what made the high (and then blood) elves look like they do, as opposed to the night elves? They were affected by the fel taint for a relatively short time and that showed through the green eyes, but that is now fading for many of them, so they are returning to their former arcane-and-light-infused selves with golden and blue eyes.
Not saying that new things cannot be added - I just donât see why this specific additional customization would be necessary or fit the lore, unless we discover yet another group of isolated elves that was changed by the light more than the âregularâ high/blood elves.
Said that, playing as a Blood Elf I must agree that tattoos, and scarring would have to be the main/priority features for them.
But I also think that red eyes could be cool, even though I donât see a Dark Ranger class being implemented on the base that they are Hunters (we see them in the Legion Class Hall) and another elf-only hero class would be boring.
Sure, the Forsaken race got red eyes customization together with all the other colors⌠problem being, their body ainât that of an elf. So as a player, if I want to play a Dark Ranger, I am forced to roll an elf.